I wrote:

Imagine a busy official at the SEC gets the letter from the expert. He leafs through the first few pages. It is written by a smart aleck anonymous person who declares himself a world-class expert, and who accuses one of the most important people on Wall Street of running a $50 billion scam. That seems so unlikely that I suppose a lot of people would not bother to read the letter carefully. They might glance at it, conclude that the author must be a nutcase or a character assassin, and then toss it out.

The parallel to cold fusion is so obvious it hardly needs mentioning, but for the record, it goes like this:

Imagine a busy scientist at a university who gets an e-mail from me. He glances at it. It is written by a smart-alack programmer who seems to think himself a world-class expert, and to claims that many important scientists have confirmed cold fusion. That seems so unlikely he does not bother to read the letter carefully. He concludes I must be a nutcase and tosses it out.

I am sure this has happened many times, because I have received responses saying I am a nutcase; that the experts I refer to are imaginary; and even that I invented the papers at LENR-CANR.org. My correspondents apparently believe that is a more plausible scenario than that hundreds of scientists have actually confirmed cold fusion and published ~3,000 papers. (Some of them dispute these numbers, and continue to dispute them after I refer them to http://lenr-canr.org/DetailOnly.htm and I suggest that they count the number of author names and titles, or go to the library and check to see if these papers really are on file. This is an extreme example of refusing to look at the data!)

One problem here is that many cold fusion researchers refuse to speak for themselves, leaving only me to speak for them.

The other problem is that my skeptical correspondents have -- in my opinion -- taken leave of their senses when they imagine that I could write 500 fake scientific papers!

- Jed

Reply via email to