On Feb 11, 2009, at 7:54 PM, Jed Rothwell wrote:
Edmund Storms wrote:
I'm inclined to conclude that the SEC ignored the letter simply
because no one below the top officials wanted the risk of rocking
the boat. Most people simply do not want to do anything that will
jeopardize their personal career.
I thought about this possibility, but I do not think it is likely.
Anyone in the SEC who heard about Madoff, and believed the
allegations were true (or probably true), would make some surefire
predictions:
1. The truth must get out, and probably soon. No Ponzi scheme lasts
long.
2. When the truth does come out, the matter will be investigated by
high officials and the Congress. It is the biggest scam in history,
after all!
3. Anyone at any level in the SEC who is found to have had knowledge
of the event will be in dire trouble. At least he will lose his job;
at worse he will end up in jail.
This would be the reaction of a logical person who had courage.
However, any individual who did something would immediately pay a
price. Their enthusiasm would bring them to the attention of upper
level people, who might be friends of Madoff. By doing nothing, they
could count on claiming that they did not believe the letter or did
not read it. I imagine the person getting the letter would discuss
the implication with his immediate boss. The advice would be to ignore
the letter, whereupon the letter would disappear. Now we only have
the claim of the writer, which focuses responsibility on no one in
particular. I doubt the letter was seen by upper level people because
everyone knew that they did not want to do anything that would
interfere with the normal operation of the market, which the Madoff
fund appeared to follow on the surface. But you ask, so what? I'm
simply trying to show how a bureaucracy operates based on the attitude
of the person at the top. If the person at the top has courage and
higher ideals, the people at lower levels will be able to exhibit
these qualities. Otherwise, these characteristics will be suppressed,
as was done during the Bush years.
Ed