Jed wrote:

>>Even so it would still be more efficient than Newman's machine+pump 
>>(775 GPH vs 540 GPH for the same 120" head and 120W power 
>>consumption), for rather less bulk and expense.
> 
> There is no doubt about that! The FT-1300 pond pump is 8" x 5" x 5" 
> (20 cm x 12 cm x 12 cm), whereas Newman's gadget incorporates 
> 1,200-lb rotary and a 450-lb flywheel! However, let us be fair to 
> Newman. It is a proof-of-principle device. If it actually produces 
> 120 W of anomalous excess power, it does not matter how big the thing is.

Nothing anomalous about the 120W, it's his input power (from the solar panels).

About Jones's remark that Newman is self-deceived, I suspect he deceives others 
than more than he deceives himself.

Michel

>> > Note that the small pumps rated <500 GPH or less cannot even reach 120":
>>
>>I think it's more a question of whether they are designed for this 
>>kind of head than a question of flow rate, most fountain pumps don't 
>>have to fight a large head.
> 
> With a 25 W 310 GPH pump, if you hold the hose up 3 meters in the 
> air, the flow will stop altogether. It cannot overcome the weight of 
> water in the hose.
> 
> 
>> > - Jed, who spent last weekend slopping around cleaning up the pond
>>
>>Harvesting algae for biofuel you mean ;-)
> 
> Fertilizing the garden with it.
> 
> The algae and slop from freshwater fish pond makes excellent 
> fertilizer. In some parts of Asia, ponds and rice paddies have kept 
> the land fertile for thousands of years with no loss of topsoil, even 
> on very rugged, steep hills with terraced fields. The ecology in many 
> parts of Japan has been changed over the last 2000 years because of 
> the widespread use rice cultivation, and the seasonal flooding of the land.
> 
> - Jed
>

Reply via email to