Hi Jed,

Jed Rothwell wrote:

>>(*) 9 gallons per mn is 9*3.8/60 = 0.57kg/s.
>>Energy required to lift  0.57 kg up 10ft=3m is 
>>m*g*h=0.57*9.81*3=17J, and 17J per s is 17W.
> 
> That can't be right. I have a 30 W pond pump that could not begin to 
> pump 9 gallons per minute 10 feet high. I could test it and find out . . .
> 
> I think this does not include the friction from the hose and pump, 

Indeed, the calculation only includes useful power (work against gravity per 
unit time).

> which is considerable. 9 gallons per minute = 540 gallons per hour 
> (GPH). 10 feet = 120" head. A pond pump rated for that kind of flow 
> draws ~120 W. See:
> 
> http://www.fountainmountain.com/largepumps.htm
> 
> On this page, you would need the model FT-1300, which at 120" 
> delivers 775 gallons. When level it delivers 1300 GPH. It is rated at 
> 120 W and based on my experience with pond pumps, I'll bet it draws 
> the whole 120 W with a 10-foot head.

Even so it would still be more efficient than Newman's machine+pump (775 GPH vs 
540 GPH for the same 120" head and 120W power consumption), for rather less 
bulk and expense.
 
> Note that the small pumps rated <500 GPH or less cannot even reach 120":

I think it's more a question of whether they are designed for this kind of head 
than a question of flow rate, most fountain pumps don't have to fight a large 
head.

> http://www.fountainmountain.com/mediumpumps.htm
> 
> That has been my experience.
> 
> See also:
> 
> http://www.fountainmountain.com/choosing_a_fountain_pump.htm
> 
> - Jed, who spent last weekend slopping around cleaning up the pond

Harvesting algae for biofuel you mean ;-)

Michel

Reply via email to