Michel Jullian wrote:

> It is a proof-of-principle device. If it actually produces
> 120 W of anomalous excess power, it does not matter how big the thing is.

Nothing anomalous about the 120W, it's his input power (from the solar panels).

Yes, I should have noted that is what he says.

However, the machine must have significant friction other that the water pumping. If it is not a siphon and it really does raise 208 GPH of water 3 meters high, and it also overcomes the friction from the 1,200-lb rotary and 450-lb flywheel, that is remarkable. On the face of it, I doubt that much energy could be generated by solar panels rated at "just under" 120 W.

It is difficult to judge. It would not be difficult if proper instruments were used. In the past Newman has not used proper instruments. I do not understand why he fools around pumping water if he actually has ~120 W anomalous excess power. Obviously he should just let the machine keep running itself. Jones Beene recommended: "SELF POWER only and for at least a few weeks!" I do not see why it needs to be so long. A few hours, or ten minutes would convincing, unless people suspect there is a hidden battery.

Jim Griggs told me that he once saw the Newman machine running. He said, as I recall, that it was self-powering but he was not impressed because it produced very little excess power. He said he could stop it by putting the palm of his hand against the end of the spinning rotor. I told him, "any excess at all would be astounding." I do not think the message sank in. He could be abuse at times. Who knows whether to believe his account?

- Jed

Reply via email to