I would like to make a suggestion and consider the points that were
addressed by Marc. Main point for me is that notifications should appear
in a corner. And imo the notifications look quite misplaced currently.
Also I would rather not be able to see the window decoration for a
second than the window's content. For these two reasons I would prefer
another solution to the synch/asynch-problem. The differentiation into
sync and async notifies itself is not as bad as I thought in the
beginning, but still, placing the notifications so low as a consequence
just seems plain wrong.
So my suggestion is (similar to Greg Nicholson's and others) to keep the
differentiation but place the synchronous notifications somewhere else
(e.g. centred on the screen, maybe even for a little shortened period)
while keeping the asynchronous notifications in the corner. (Yes, I
know, that might seem MAC-like to some but just because someone already
thought of it, does not automatically mean it's wrong.) Or, to get back
to the points, Marc made:
"The factors that need to be considered are:
* fitting things into the corner is most aesthetically pleasing"
true. +1
" * the "synchronous" notifications [...] are fixed in size"
Okilidokili, they can appear centred and fade out after a second or so.
" * the async notifications [...] are variable sized and can grow vertically"
Shouldn't be a problem any more because the synchronous notifications are out
of the way
" * sliding things around when something else grows is really bad, it is
unpredictable and frustrating for a user trying to look at the thing
that suddenly moves, so:
- synchronous should not be below async (so that it does not have to slide
down)
- the bottom right corner doesn't work (because then async has to grow
"upwards")"
Ok, so no movement of the notifications. Let's stick with the sequential
appear-disappear solution. Also as I said above: "Shouldn't be a problem any
more because the synchronous notifications are out of the way."
" * the top right corner has a lot of stuff there - window decorations, tabs,
tab controls (new tab, close tab etc) and in many apps, a search input. So even
though the look-through and click-through is *cool*, it's still better not to
put async right into the top right corner"
That's where I disagree for three reasons: 1.) "fitting things into the corner
is most aesthetically pleasing", 2.) If I had to decide between seeing the
decoration and the window's content, I would always go for the window's
content. And 3.) If I really had to press a button (new tab or so) in that
exact second, I would have to move my cursor there anyway, thus making the
notification transparent.
--
Notifications should show up closer to top right
https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/438536
You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu
Bugs, which is subscribed to Ubuntu.
--
ubuntu-bugs mailing list
ubuntu-bugs@lists.ubuntu.com
https://lists.ubuntu.com/mailman/listinfo/ubuntu-bugs
