On Fri, May 25, 2001 at 10:04:28PM -0700 or thereabouts, Stacy Brock wrote:
> > Methinks there is a significant amount of
> > Debian snobbishness floating around, not too unlike
> > the Gnome vs. KDE desktop wars. Why a distro has to
> > be un-user friendly to be cool is beyond me, and that
> > certainly is Debian's reputation.
>
> Oooh, I just have to jump into the thread on this one.
> ;) Please send comments to me, or post them to issues,
> as I'm skirting the Line of OT-ness.
issues is more for women and IT/Linux/etc, so I'm sticking
to techtalk.
> I'm a relative Linux newbie (I've been running Linux
> solely on my main box for about 6 months now). I also
> use Debian.
>
> Guess what? Even for this newbie, the install was NOT as
> difficult as everyone makes it out to be. The Ncurses
> GUI installer may not have the pretty penguin pictures
> that Mandrake 7 and 8 has, but it works. Since Debian's
> installer now uses "make menuconfig" instead of "make
> config"...setup is fairly straightforward.
What other OSes had you had experience of, though? Had
you installed those before? Are you happy adding stuff to
your box? There's a lot of people for whom "I got more
memory" means "and now I have to take it down to the shop
and pay someone to put it in for me". If you know that
your mouse is a USB mouse, then you're one ahead already :)
I am very used to RH and only a little used to Debian, and
I had less trouble than I expected installing, but then,
I read the docs, and I knew what most of the packages were.
Also, I had heard so much about "dselect hell" that I was
prepared for a long haul.
> I've heard a saying among Debian users that goes like
> this: "If you can't install it [Debian], you shouldn't
> be using it." If you call that snobbishness, I can't
> help you.
I do find the statement "if you can't install foo, you
shouldn't use it" faintly snobbish, I must admit. I am
not stupid and I do read docs. When there are none, I
write the things. But then, I have been -using- Linux
for a very long time: my husband was the one who installed
it originally. Should I have avoided it until I was able
to install it? I only learned the things I needed to know
to install by using the thing in the first place.
> However, I think that the saying really means
> this: "If you aren't patient enough to RTFM, you
> shouldn't be using it [Debian]."
> And I think that applies to Linux as a whole as well. :)
I have to throw in a comment that is not original to me
here. It comes from Jon Lasser's "Think Unix" book, which I
heartily recommend to anyone. It's short but very sweet.
He begins by telling people how to get the most out of
man pages and other sources of documentation, which is a
sensible approach. His exercises at the back of each chapter
had me realising how much I did or didn't know and what I
had been missing.
The footnote for a particular example:
Actually I was rather disturbed to find that the Linux man page
for logout is totally useless for normal people and that Irix
doesn't even have a man page for this. Of course, there's a perfectly
logical deep technical reason for this, but it's still a bad idea.
Shame on all you developers.
And another example that happened to me yesterday. I wanted a quick
way to convert between binary, "normal" numbers, and hex. At first
I thought 'od' might help, and failing that, I thought 'dc'. 'od'
didn't help, and with a sigh I turned to 'man dc'. I couldn't find
anything remotely helpful. Then a friend on IRC told me how to do
this: 2o[number]p for "turn [number] into binary". I went back to
the man page and found "o - Pops the value off the top of the stack
and uses it to set the output radix".
Of course. How could I have seen 'output radix' and failed to realise
this meant "base" and that popping the value of the top of the stack
was exactly what I wanted to do? (Note, I dropped maths at 16, and
my limited language knowledge gave me the idea that radix meant root :))
Then there is the man page for CVS. All I wanted was "how do I
get a list of all the modules in this CVS tree?" After a friend
told me about "cvs checkout -c" I was able to find the one sentence
in the very long page which explained it, but what I really learned
was "how the cvs man page describes what anyone else would call
'getting a list of the modules available'".
So yes, reading the documentation helps, but it takes a lot of
practice to understand it.
Telsa
_______________________________________________
techtalk mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://www.linux.org.uk/mailman/listinfo/techtalk
