I am not a address mapper. I only notice that mapping done by you before and the data available for Padova, but not imported, differ systematically. We have in Veneto so many bad-data-import problems, I just want to prevent another one, that I discovered more or less accidentally.
On Sun, 6 Oct 2024, 07:24 , <szyd...@poczta.onet.pl> wrote: > Hi Volker > > *"Please suspend that operation until we have a clarification."* > OK, I got no problem with that, but which aspects of the data do you still > need to clarify further ? > > Best regards > Premislav > > W dniu 2024-10-05 23:10:08 użytkownik Volker Schmidt napisał: > > Sorry, no, it does not dispell my doubts. > Please suspend that operation until we have a clarification. > > Good night > > On Sat, 5 Oct 2024 at 21:38, Premislav via Talk-it < > talk-it@openstreetmap.org> wrote: > >> Hi Volker >> >> *„My observations: many, but not all addresses are inside buildings, and >> not on the entrance.*„ >> >> Unfortunately in that region many building outlines are not precise (were >> drawn a long time ago from outdated or misaligned Bing imagery), so >> sometimes addresses indeed land up inside buildings (sometimes the building >> even cross highways, in that case I better them using my normal account >> where I can). Consulting previous imports I was instructed not to “drag” >> addresses to edges of the outlines of the buildings, but leave them as they >> were in the database. Once imported they could be be dragged by local >> surveys to the exact position (sometimes only some meters away). This does >> not mean the address data should be considered wrong, but rather that the >> buildings outlines should be bettered. >> >> *I don't know if this is valid nation-wide, but certainly here in Padova >> (my present home town) the house numbers are on the location of the >> entrance, often some meters away. * >> >> As far as I saw this can be different in Italy. Sometimes the address is >> placed on the gate(usually in cases where there is a fence fencing off the >> real estate), but also on the door of the building (usually in case where >> the door is accessible directly from the street. >> >> *In contrast I could not find out where your data came from.* >> As written on the source page >> <https://innovationlabdolomiti.openpa.opencontent.io/Dataset/Numeri-civici-Comune-di-Valle-di-Cadore#informazioni_sul_dataset> >> , the data comes from the commune itself >> *“Titolare del dataset* >> *Comune di Valle di Cadore”* >> >> *Sorry to be cautious* >> I hope this answers your questions and dispels your doubts. >> >> Best regards >> Premislav >> >> W dniu 2024-10-04 23:34:36 użytkownik Volker Schmidt napisał: >> >> Hi Premislav, >> Please do not proceed before we have clarified several points. >> >> Why: >> I live in Padova, the same Region of Italy, but a different Province. >> I have inspected a small sample of your recently imported data in Borca >> di Cadore. >> My observations: many, but not all addresses are inside buildings, and >> not on the entrance. This is contrary to what I believed was standard >> around here. I don't know if this is valid nation-wide, but certainly here >> in Padova (my present home town) the house numbers are on the location of >> the entrance, often some meters away. This data regards the equivalent data >> for Padova in the same regional database you use as source. However the >> difference is that the Padova data are provided by the city's own services. >> In contrast I could not find out where your data came from. It looks very >> much as if some voluntary contributor has created address data for an open >> access-public data base, used in Province of Belluno using OSM data as >> source: We have to find out more about both aspects before proceeding. >> >> Sorry to be cautious >> >> Volker >> >> >> On Fri, 4 Oct 2024 at 13:13, Premislav via Talk-it < >> talk-it@openstreetmap.org> wrote: >> >>> Hi IT-community :) >>> >>> After completion of the import of house numbers in San Vito di Cadore, >>> Borca di Cadore, Auronzo di Cadore/Belluno, I'm planning to continue >>> importing missing addresses in other communes of the Belluno region. >>> This time with Valle di Cadore. >>> The necessary data is provided by the Comune di Valle di Cadore as >>> Public Domain, the importing procedure would be the similar as last time. >>> A corresponding wiki page is already present >>> <https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Valle_di_Cadore_house_number_import> >>> . >>> I’d like to start the import in the end of current and in next mouth >>> (end October/November 2024). >>> If you have any comments until then, feel free to contact me. >>> >>> Best greetings >>> Premislav >>> _______________________________________________ >>> Talk-it mailing list >>> Talk-it@openstreetmap.org >>> https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-it >>> >> >> >> _______________________________________________ >> Talk-it mailing list >> Talk-it@openstreetmap.org >> https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-it >> > >
_______________________________________________ Talk-it mailing list Talk-it@openstreetmap.org https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-it
