Mar 15, 2019, 10:03 AM by rich...@systemed.net: > Mateusz Konieczny wrote: > >> Yes, one of main points of StreetComplete is to allow editing >> without knowing how objects are tagged, similarly iD. >> >> It means that to count "how many people decided to use tag >> XYZ" all iD users and all StreetComplete users count as say >> 4 people because not each mapper is deciding on its own >> but it is decision of whoever makes the software. >> > > Oh, come on. Just because iD has an actual user interface doesn't mean that > every single iD user is unaware of the tags used. There are plenty of > experienced mappers (I'm one) who choose not to use JOSM because they just > don't like JOSM, believe it or not! > Thanks, I was unaware about it! I was always really frustrated by iD hiding tags and requiring scrolling to get it (and really slow performance). I admit that I was unaware that it is used as a primary editor also by people editing tags directly. Sorry for spreading misinformation. > On topic: I don't have a great preference for either tagging scheme (they're > both a bit ungainly, I've found them both a bit of a PITA to support in > cycle.travel's tag parsing). cycleway=opposite_lane is concise but unclear. > Regardless, both are in widespread use so the wiki should document both. > Yes, if both are in a widespread use then both should be described. Claim that opposite_lane is a value that has no meaning with cycleway:left that appeared on Wiki (in edit description) is completely untrue. Maybe some people dislike this tag and it is more confusing than it should be but it has a known meaning.
_______________________________________________ Tagging mailing list Tagging@openstreetmap.org https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging
