Am 18.10.2012 17:16, schrieb Simone Saviolo:
[...]
Peter, I am just a little bit dubious about the guideline you
described. A good marketing campaign would include (if multiple social
services are used) a website with the main content and regular posts
on the social networks about instant news. Usually the website would
have a link to those social networks, so tagging the website alone
would be all that's needed. However, suppose the website of a
restaurant shows one type of information (maybe something static like
the menu) and all the "important" news is on the restaurant's Facebook
page, which is not linked to from the site. Or suppose that different
services (the website, the Facebook page, and the Twitter stream)
provided different kinds of information and contact. Would you be for
or against tagging them all, in that case?
Usually yes.
OSM is no marketing support tool.
OSM is not and IMHO should not be responsible to tie different parts of
a bad marketing campaign together.
As you wrote yourself: "Usually the website would have a link to those
social networks, so tagging the website alone would be all that's needed."
For me that is: Use that central website as website, and nothing else.
If there isn't (e.g. because it's NOT a GOOD marketing campaign) use no
website at all or choose one you know.
If the most central website of the facility is the facebook website,
well... use that in osm, (probably add "if it's relevant for the POI
(and not for marketing only)", as you like personally).
regards
Peter
_______________________________________________
Tagging mailing list
Tagging@openstreetmap.org
http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging
