Re: [Tagging] What to map a site of historical significants...

2011-04-28 Thread M∡rtin Koppenhoefer
2011/4/28 Simone Saviolo : > phase maps. For example, I've mapped memorial sites related to battles of > the Italian Risorgimento, but not the place where the battles themselves > took place. Also, I've mapped many plates dedicated to kings, soldiers and > patriots, because they're things that are

Re: [Tagging] What to map a site of historical significants...

2011-04-28 Thread Simone Saviolo
2011/4/28 Richard Welty > On 4/27/11 8:47 PM, John Smith wrote: > >> >> If people can tag trees, surely things of historical significants >> deserve to be allowed in OSM as well. >> > identifiable, physical objects that exist today, sure. > > the phase maps i want to do for the battle of antietam

Re: [Tagging] What to map a site of historical significants...

2011-04-28 Thread John Smith
On 28 April 2011 17:56, M∡rtin Koppenhoefer wrote: > historic=event and event=? > or historic:event=yes/ ? I like this suggestion. I noticed in JOSM there is a historic=battlefield, but this and other similar events, like David's suggestion about the great train robbery, would be good to be group

Re: [Tagging] What to map a site of historical significants...

2011-04-28 Thread M∡rtin Koppenhoefer
2011/4/28 David Murn : > That doesnt detract from the original question, of what to map a site of > historic significance. historic=event and event=? or historic:event=yes/ ? the ever useful, never descriptive tourism=attraction could also be used. cheers, Martin __

Re: [Tagging] What to map a site of historical significants...

2011-04-27 Thread John Smith
On 28 April 2011 11:40, Richard Welty wrote: > On 4/27/11 8:47 PM, John Smith wrote: >> >> If people can tag trees, surely things of historical significants >> deserve to be allowed in OSM as well. > > identifiable, physical objects that exist today, sure. That's the catch, there is no marker sig

Re: [Tagging] What to map a site of historical significants...

2011-04-27 Thread Richard Welty
On 4/27/11 8:47 PM, John Smith wrote: If people can tag trees, surely things of historical significants deserve to be allowed in OSM as well. identifiable, physical objects that exist today, sure. the phase maps i want to do for the battle of antietam (September 1862), not so much. richard

Re: [Tagging] What to map a site of historical significants...

2011-04-27 Thread John Smith
On 28 April 2011 10:35, David Murn wrote: > I agree in part, but this isnt just any news story or photo. +1 > That doesnt detract from the original question, of what to map a site of > historic significance. Im sure the location of the great train robbery > or an the location of the site of an

Re: [Tagging] What to map a site of historical significants...

2011-04-27 Thread David Murn
On Wed, 2011-04-27 at 19:33 +0100, Laurence Penney wrote: > Historical event geotagging could rapidly get out of hand. This feels > to me very much orthogonal to OSM - almost every news story, photo, > work of art, etc arguably deserves a geotag, but hardly any of them > deserve to be in OSM. I ag

Re: [Tagging] What to map a site of historical significants...

2011-04-27 Thread Richard Welty
On 4/27/11 2:33 PM, Laurence Penney wrote: Historical event geotagging could rapidly get out of hand. This feels to me very much orthogonal to OSM - almost every news story, photo, work of art, etc arguably deserves a geotag, but hardly any of them deserve to be in OSM. A separate database is

Re: [Tagging] What to map a site of historical significants...

2011-04-27 Thread Laurence Penney
Historical event geotagging could rapidly get out of hand. This feels to me very much orthogonal to OSM - almost every news story, photo, work of art, etc arguably deserves a geotag, but hardly any of them deserve to be in OSM. A separate database is where things like this should reside, where a

[Tagging] What to map a site of historical significants...

2011-04-23 Thread John Smith
Does any one have any thoughts on what to tag a location famous for 2 reasons, first it was a spot where a stage coach was held up by thunderbolt, secondly because someone did a painting of the event after the event: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bailed_Up There is no marker at the site or anythin