[RBW] Re: The way I design a build, and the first chapter

2024-12-04 Thread Armand Kizirian
Thanks Ted, I realized my flat pedals for my mtb that I never use could easily be used on my Riv. Saved 166g / 0.36lbs. Never was quite thrilled with the MKS Pretzel platform, the Stamp 7 replacement is welcomed, after swapping the screws/pins for a much less aggressive height to not destroy th

[RBW] Re: The way I design a build, and the first chapter

2024-12-04 Thread Bill Lindsay
Collin gave the heads up that Paragon Machine works, just down the hill in Richmond, is (practically) giving away house made titanium bolts. I visited them and bought 20 M5x0.8x10mm (aka water bottle bolts), 10 M5x0.8x16mm (aka front derailleur clamp bolts), and 5 M6x1.0x30mm (aka threadless t

Re: [RBW] Re: The way I design a build, and the first chapter

2024-12-03 Thread brendonoid
*Jason Fuller:* *Crust makes some really light-for-their-width options but I've seen too many crack at the eyelets for me to buy them.* Ah, you just saved me a lot of money. Thanks. Well not really because Quills cost a lot more but you know what I mean... -- You received this message because yo

Re: [RBW] Re: The way I design a build, and the first chapter

2024-12-03 Thread Richard Rose
Interesting. I did not think the quill could take a 55. But even that is a far cry from my 2.6” tires.Regarding the dynamo - I got a nice deal on the wheels & envisioned some possible nighttime adventures in addition to standard MTB duties. So far it’s been exclusively MTB - nothing at night.Sent f

[RBW] Re: The way I design a build, and the first chapter

2024-12-03 Thread Jason Fuller
Richard - regarding the weight of dynamo, a friend did a pretty comprehensive gram-counting exercise on dynamo vs. battery lights and found that dynamo is about 170g heavier on average, if I'm remembering correctly. It assumes though that you're carrying battery lights if you don't have dynamo

[RBW] Re: The way I design a build, and the first chapter

2024-12-03 Thread Collin A
To pile onto the bolt-gram-counting-train, Paragon Machine Works is having a holiday sale and you can get some nice M5 and M6 Ti bolts for about $1-2 each. That falls under Bill's $1/g (approximate) limit. Bonus for being local! I picked up a few for fender mounting and to save some weight on t

[RBW] Re: The way I design a build, and the first chapter

2024-12-03 Thread Bill Lindsay
In my original post I said: "The bolts gives (sic) the opportunity to do some gram-chasing." I got a $90 McMaster-Carr order in today, featuring 20 aluminum bolts and 8 Titanium bolts. By my count, I think 10 of those 28 bolts are going to end up on my CHG build. Bill Lindsay El Cerrito,

Re: [RBW] Re: The way I design a build, and the first chapter

2024-12-03 Thread Richard Rose
I almost forgot. The wheelset I kind of fell into (Cliffhanger’s) came with a Son dynamo hub. I still do not own a dynamo powered light two years on. I think it’s a relative boat anchor? So yeah, an alternate wheelset might make a difference I would notice. Lastly there is the Silver double crank v

Re: [RBW] Re: The way I design a build, and the first chapter

2024-12-03 Thread Bill Lindsay
It sounds to me like you have a good handle on the trade-offs. Good luck if you decide to do something BL in EC On Tuesday, December 3, 2024 at 10:53:08 AM UTC-8 Richard Rose wrote: > Fair points. FYI, the Susie is (I think?) 8 ounces lighter. If I was truly > concerned I could shed the B17 &

Re: [RBW] Re: The way I design a build, and the first chapter

2024-12-03 Thread Richard Rose
Fair points. FYI, the Susie is (I think?) 8 ounces lighter. If I was truly concerned I could shed the B17 & steel Albacore handlebar for instant weight loss, but I love both.Sent from my iPhoneOn Dec 3, 2024, at 12:29 PM, Bill Lindsay wrote:A gram-shaving Gus build sounds to me like a Susie build

Re: [RBW] Re: The way I design a build, and the first chapter

2024-12-03 Thread Bill Lindsay
A gram-shaving Gus build sounds to me like a Susie build ;-). Rim-brake rim options for wide tires are indeed slim. I've heard of an Alex DX-32 which may be ~75g lighter than a Cliffhanger. In my stable, when the tires get that wide, that's where we switch over to disc brakes, which opens up

Re: [RBW] Re: The way I design a build, and the first chapter

2024-12-03 Thread Richard Rose
Thanks for that. I love every single thing about my Gus & it’s build - except its weight. It’s a heavy beast & it only bothers me going uphill on singletrack. When I built it up from bare frame I paid no attention to weight. I even (foolishly?) sold a Cane Creek ee wings Ti crankset to fund the fra

[RBW] Re: The way I design a build, and the first chapter

2024-12-03 Thread Ted Durant
On Monday, December 2, 2024 at 9:33:16 AM UTC-6 Bill Lindsay wrote: Somebody off-list told me that plastic sealed bearing Clem pedals are impressively light. As I posted earlier in this thread, I weighed a pair of them at 272g, including the plastic shrink-wrap holding them together :-) The

[RBW] Re: The way I design a build, and the first chapter

2024-12-02 Thread Bill Lindsay
CONFIRMED! All of you who bought a CLEM complete from Rivendell are now confirmed as Weight Weenies!! Pop those reflectors off to save a gram or two! BL in EC On Monday, December 2, 2024 at 7:51:04 AM UTC-8 Ted Durant wrote: > On Monday, December 2, 2024 at 9:33:16 AM UTC-6 Bill Lindsay wrot

Re: [RBW] Re: The way I design a build, and the first chapter

2024-12-02 Thread Armand Kizirian
Sure, feels a bit snappier off the line and surprisingly fast for an upright bike (nice tires with light wheels mostly help here). If you get really active with the bike, go for a spirited sprint, or chuck it in some turns at an aggressive speed, the weight shift does feel more noticeable. It's

Re: [RBW] Re: The way I design a build, and the first chapter

2024-12-02 Thread Richard Rose
Very fascinating stuff. Two questions; how much did the 4+ pound weight loss cost & how does it feel? Sent from my iPhoneOn Dec 2, 2024, at 7:06 PM, Armand Kizirian wrote:Whoops! Good catch. From what's identified on that list, the correct total is 1938g / 4.27lbs. I feel silly after all that wei

[RBW] Re: The way I design a build, and the first chapter

2024-12-02 Thread Armand Kizirian
Whoops! Good catch. From what's identified on that list, the correct total is 1938g / 4.27lbs. I feel silly after all that weighing and I didn't weigh the complete bike stock. Oh well! The 2.5lb+ drop in wheel weight also includes the exceptionally light, extralight rene herse casing, and ligh

[RBW] Re: The way I design a build, and the first chapter

2024-12-02 Thread Bill Lindsay
Looks like 1188g of savings is the SUM of both wheels reduction. 670g + 518g = 1,188g Now it makes sense. Did you double-count the front wheel savings in your total though? Maybe it doesn't matter anymore. :) BL in EC On Monday, December 2, 2024 at 2:44:17 PM UTC-8 Bill Lindsay wrote: > I

[RBW] Re: The way I design a build, and the first chapter

2024-12-02 Thread Bill Lindsay
I don't follow the math. The rear wheel math makes sense to me: Heavy old rear wheel weight - Lighter new rear wheel weight = rear wheel weight savings 2252g - 1582g =670g = 23.634 oz (checks out) Heavy old front wheel weight - Lighter new front wheel weight = front wheel weight savings 1942g

[RBW] Re: The way I design a build, and the first chapter

2024-12-02 Thread Armand Kizirian
For reference, I reduced the weight of my Platypus Complete by 5.75lbs. I stripped the parts entirely for another frame, which was the plan from the get go. The list below shows the weight difference of parts. It is mostly complete, but missing brakes and some other accessories, because I ultim

[RBW] Re: The way I design a build, and the first chapter

2024-12-02 Thread Bill Lindsay
"The sum total of all of the above is sitting at 9025g. The numbers will change a little when I get the actual frame set in my hands, and figure out places for lighter fasteners." And indeed a few grams have dropped: My seatpost and chainring were on my porch when I got home from visiting my

[RBW] Re: The way I design a build, and the first chapter

2024-12-01 Thread Bill Lindsay
Ted - I'm surprised you think I glossed over my cassette. Maybe you are one of the members who views the group on your email client, making it almost impossible to follow a multipost thread? Anyway, the cassette is attached to the rear wheel, so I count it as part of section 2: Wheel set. Th

[RBW] Re: The way I design a build, and the first chapter

2024-12-01 Thread Ted Durant
On Friday, November 29, 2024 at 12:28:42 PM UTC-6 Bill Lindsay wrote: I'll probably employ the contemporary iBob trick to run one narrower generation chain (9sp) on my 8sp cassette. The 8 gears will run between 33 and 87 gear inches. Hey Bill - I'm surprised you glossed over the choice of

[RBW] Re: The way I design a build, and the first chapter

2024-12-01 Thread Bill Lindsay
Rounding out the build plans there are sections 4 and 5. Components and Accessories. Components in a way should come first on a Rivendell build because the first thing we normally think about when defining the broad strokes of a Riv build is the handlebar. In no particular order, Components

Re: [RBW] Re: The way I design a build, and the first chapter

2024-11-30 Thread Ted Durant
On Saturday, November 30, 2024 at 10:34:03 AM UTC-6 John Dewey wrote: Gram counting is primarily an intellectual exercise is it not? I don't think so. In some sense it's purely a physical exercise, removing mass from the bike. Or, as Bill has noted, it can be a financial exercise, calculating

Re: [RBW] Re: The way I design a build, and the first chapter

2024-11-30 Thread John Dewey
Gram counting is primarily an intellectual exercise is it not? For sure, light wheels are sublime if you can get away with it. I gave up on sew-ups long ago but I’ll never forget my first ride on those I built for a Torpado race bike I owned while living on Nantucket. Transformative, oh my! I’m not

Re: [RBW] Re: The way I design a build, and the first chapter

2024-11-30 Thread Ted Durant
Fun thread. Reminds me of "It's All About The Bike" by Robert Penn. I'm also a spreadsheet jockey (I recently said to a retired-actuary-biking friend, "If it can't be done in a spreadsheet, it's not worth doing."), and I have a column for component weights, but I haven't used that column in a l

Re: [RBW] Re: The way I design a build, and the first chapter

2024-11-29 Thread brendonoid
I look forward to the next part Bill, Thanks. My usual method is throw my parts bin at a frame and see what sticks then open 50+tabs in my browser and see what arrives in the mail a month later. This method seems more organised. -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Go

Re: [RBW] Re: The way I design a build, and the first chapter

2024-11-29 Thread Patrick Moore
Sheesh: 12-21. I sometimes swapped in a 13-23. On Fri, Nov 29, 2024 at 4:23 PM Patrick Moore wrote: > … 12-19 Am Classic 10 spee > -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "RBW Owners Bunch" group. To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails fr

Re: [RBW] Re: The way I design a build, and the first chapter

2024-11-29 Thread Patrick Moore
Xpedo. On Fri, Nov 29, 2024 at 4:23 PM Patrick Moore wrote: > … Xpedia ti-spindle 2-sided SPD-type pedals > -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "RBW Owners Bunch" group. To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email t

Re: [RBW] Re: The way I design a build, and the first chapter

2024-11-29 Thread Patrick Moore
Forgot to add that the Curt frameset, 58 c-c with fork with long steerer and 2003 Ultegra headset weighed a surprisingly heavy 7 lb. On Fri, Nov 29, 2024 at 4:23 PM Patrick Moore wrote: > … the Curt came in at 19 lb even with 1X10 (TA Pro 5 Vis 48 pulling 12-19 > Am Classic 10 speed with retrofr

Re: [RBW] Re: The way I design a build, and the first chapter

2024-11-29 Thread Patrick Moore
Bill: pedals: if you wan them, I’ll send you (no cost except patience) my hitherto hoarded Xpedia ti-spindle 2-sided SPD-type pedals at IIRC 260 grams, 180 lb weight limit. I’m well under but still have qualms about torquing a 76” gear uphill with them. (My lovely DA SPDs weigh 100 grams more.) No

[RBW] Re: The way I design a build, and the first chapter

2024-11-29 Thread Bill Lindsay
I'll throw a couple more numbers around about wheels. Back in the 1980s when roadies had clinchers for "training wheels" and tubulars for "racing wheels, we picked up the number 1500g as the number for "light" wheels, without a freewheel/cassette. Without tires. Without skewers. Turns out t

[RBW] Re: The way I design a build, and the first chapter

2024-11-29 Thread Ryan
As always, Bill, your meticulous attention to detail is impressive Looking forward to the next installments of your build, and accompanying pictures. Also think that dark gold is a great color On Thursday, November 28, 2024 at 4:44:49 PM UTC-6 Jay wrote: > Thanks for taking the time to lay all

[RBW] Re: The way I design a build, and the first chapter

2024-11-28 Thread Jay
Thanks for taking the time to lay all this out, Bill. I have last year's Roadini and while it feels light with 30mm tires, I know it's punching above 20 pounds. Perhaps over time I will look to get the weight lower, as I replace parts. On Thursday, November 28, 2024 at 1:49:20 PM UTC-5 Bill L

[RBW] Re: The way I design a build, and the first chapter

2024-11-28 Thread Bill Lindsay
Hi Joyce There's an immense backstory at every single piece on this build, and I was going to meter it out one section at a time for that reason. One of the fun backstories is that my old college roommate has asked me to set aside 2+ weeks in the Summer of 2027 to do a Loire Valley cycle-tour.

[RBW] Re: The way I design a build, and the first chapter

2024-11-28 Thread JAS
Bill, This series of build descriptions is of great interest to me and so timely since my Charlie Gallup has been shipped. I appreciate your strategy explanation and it's helping me think about my own new bike. I'll have my LBS build it up; I'm consulting with them about parts on Monday. The go