[RBW] New Drivetrain Setup on the Hunqapillar

2016-04-26 Thread Ginz
I have a 2x10 hard tail and I like it. This is coming from a guy who was holding onto 9sp rapid rise like the last drop of water on earth. I don't think I'd like a 1x drivetrain because it takes many more clicks to dump a lot of gear on trails. On rolling terrain, I'm sure it's nice. The stron

[RBW] New Drivetrain Setup on the Hunqapillar

2016-04-25 Thread Bill Lindsay
Not a 100 percent tangent, but I bought a nice carbon mountain bike. I picked the best frame with mediocre parts (deore 2x10). I just bought an XTR drivetrain for it from chain reaction (also 2x10). I'm kind of toying with putting this high end drivetrain on my Atlantis instead. Just for fun.

Re: [RBW] New Drivetrain Setup on the Hunqapillar

2016-04-24 Thread Mark Reimer
Keith, what's the clearance like with those tires? I've had 2.25 in my Atlantis and it's really darn close. I've rubbed the paint off after a muddy ride. On Sunday, April 24, 2016 at 3:08:19 PM UTC-5, Patrick Moore wrote: > > That's what I hope is the case, since if I make the switch, it will

Re: [RBW] New Drivetrain Setup on the Hunqapillar

2016-04-24 Thread Patrick Moore
That's what I hope is the case, since if I make the switch, it will probably come with a switch from Origin 8 mtb bar to some sort of dirt drop bar, set high, and with this, bar end shifters. I've shifted 9 with Silvers, and I am hoping that 10 won't be that much harder. On Sun, Apr 24, 2016 at 1:

Re: [RBW] New Drivetrain Setup on the Hunqapillar

2016-04-24 Thread Patrick Moore
That is indeed the question most succinctly put. My "road bike for dirt" -- not the singletrack mountain bike -- is geared with a "subcompact" 2X9, 38 X 24, where I hardly ever use the 24, and where I shift the 9 with Silver (friction) bar end shifters. At least with friction, it's much easier to c

Re: [RBW] New Drivetrain Setup on the Hunqapillar

2016-04-24 Thread Mike in WA
I don't have personal experience with running friction on a 1X10 setup, but I think dstein's thought on it makes sense. I would bet you can go from 11-13 to 36-42 on a Sunrace 10-speed cassette by friction shifting in about the same time as it would take to drop on a front derailleur. With just

Re: [RBW] New Drivetrain Setup on the Hunqapillar

2016-04-24 Thread ted
Patrick "rhetorical question" Moore wrote: "Ted "no context" Kelly"'s reply is doubtless made to my question. But I disagree, ..." In response to my negative reply to his previous query: "Will a well considered 1X10 give you the nice, close flatland cruising gears, with bailouts just a flick or

Re: [RBW] New Drivetrain Setup on the Hunqapillar

2016-04-24 Thread Patrick Moore
I'll be interested to hear user's opinions of the advantages/disadvantages of 1Xn versus 2 or 3 Xn. I'm not convinced (yet) that a 1Xn won't work better in such situations than the other. Sure, you can't just dump the chain to a smaller ring, but OTOH, rear shifts are generally easier, faster, and

Re: [RBW] New Drivetrain Setup on the Hunqapillar

2016-04-24 Thread Matt P.
Very nice set-up! I always admire the simple look of the 1x. Seems like the Shimano XTR 1x chainring has a "Proprietary Chain Retention Technology". Not sure what this is, but it could be similar to Sram's 1x rings, with longer teeth to hold the chain better. I would like this better than my

Re: [RBW] New Drivetrain Setup on the Hunqapillar

2016-04-23 Thread David Stein
Well your question that Ted replied 'no' to was: Will a well considered 1X10 give you the nice, close flatland cruising gears, with bailouts just a flick or 2 away? Which I agree with his answer, if thats what he was answering. By giving up the front options, you can't just 'flick' the front derai

Re: [RBW] New Drivetrain Setup on the Hunqapillar

2016-04-23 Thread Patrick Moore
Ted "no context" Kelly"'s reply is doubtless made to my question. But I disagree, at least theoretically, and I'd like to hear from others who have actually made the change, and have used both systems, and have concrete experience to relate. This is what I've thought of: 34.0 11.0 83.5 13.0 70.1

Re: [RBW] New Drivetrain Setup on the Hunqapillar

2016-04-23 Thread ted
No -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "RBW Owners Bunch" group. To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to rbw-owners-bunch+unsubscr...@googlegroups.com. To post to this group, send email to rbw-owners-bunch@googl

Re: [RBW] New Drivetrain Setup on the Hunqapillar

2016-04-23 Thread Patrick Moore
All of this list interest in 1 X n drivetrains; I'm intrigued. I'll be interested to hear how this compares to the 3Xn or 2Xn originals, particularly for somewhat technical riding -- ie, where you have to dump or gain large gear differences right away. I just rode my '96 (Santa Cruz-built, please)