Re: Dial Concentrators - TNT / APX8000 R.I.P.

2010-05-14 Thread joel jaeggli
On 2010-05-14 22:04, Alastair Johnson wrote: Mark Foster wrote: What about developing nations where Internet isn't yet as commonplace as it is in the 'west' ? They skip dialup. dial modems are the end game for a 140 year old technology (300-3400hz pots lines). There is literally no reaso

Re: Dial Concentrators - TNT / APX8000 R.I.P.

2010-05-14 Thread Alastair Johnson
Mark Foster wrote: Thus the wider concern I flagged; if the only source for equipment and spares is the grey market, aren't the vendors missing the boat on something which shouldn't even have a major overhead to maintain? There is no sales of new chassis, which means the manufacturing is shut

Re: Dial Concentrators - TNT / APX8000 R.I.P.

2010-05-13 Thread joel jaeggli
on people, have terrestrial broadband access" http://blog.zcorum.com/2010/03/national-broadband-plan-the-debate-begins/. Frank -Original Message- From: Curtis Maurand [mailto:cmaur...@xyonet.com] Sent: Tuesday, May 11, 2010 10:51 AM To: nanog@nanog.org Subject: Re: Dial Concentrators - TNT /

RE: Dial Concentrators - TNT / APX8000 R.I.P.

2010-05-13 Thread Frank Bulk
nd access" http://blog.zcorum.com/2010/03/national-broadband-plan-the-debate-begins/. Frank -Original Message- From: Curtis Maurand [mailto:cmaur...@xyonet.com] Sent: Tuesday, May 11, 2010 10:51 AM To: nanog@nanog.org Subject: Re: Dial Concentrators - TNT / APX8000 R.I.P. 30% of all people in

Re: Dial Concentrators - TNT / APX8000 R.I.P.

2010-05-12 Thread Jared Mauch
On May 12, 2010, at 12:56 PM, JC Dill wrote: > You *can* still buy brand new buggy whips: > > http://www.jedediahsbuggywhip.com/ > http://www.drivingessentials.com/Whips.htm I get my wooden oars and paddles here: http://www.shawandtenney.com/ They are great and work well on the double-ended r

Re: Dial Concentrators - TNT / APX8000 R.I.P.

2010-05-12 Thread JC Dill
Mark Foster wrote: On Wed, May 12, 2010 4:38 am, Justin Wilson wrote: There are those ppl who just want to do e-mail, are comfortable with dial-up, don¹t want to pay for than $5-10 for internet, and can¹t get anything else. Indeed. The arguments for alternatives based on the fact they

Re: Dial Concentrators - TNT / APX8000 R.I.P.

2010-05-12 Thread sthaug
> I've heard of some LECs starting to mull dropping frame relay as a > supported service as well... The provider I work for stopped selling Frame Relay four years ago. However, we didn't throw out the last Nortel Passport switches until about one year ago. Steinar Haug, Nethelp consulting, sth..

Re: Dial Concentrators - TNT / APX8000 R.I.P.

2010-05-11 Thread Mark Foster
On Wed, May 12, 2010 4:38 am, Justin Wilson wrote: > There are those ppl who just want to do e-mail, are comfortable with > dial-up, don¹t want to pay for than $5-10 for internet, and can¹t get > anything else. Indeed. The arguments for alternatives based on the fact theyre cheap, don't counter t

Re: Dial Concentrators - TNT / APX8000 R.I.P.

2010-05-11 Thread Justin Wilson
e: Tue, 11 May 2010 12:32:56 -0400 To: 'Mark Foster' , 'Bill Fehring' Cc: Subject: RE: Dial Concentrators - TNT / APX8000 R.I.P. When I sold my business in January, we still had 4 PRI circuits that were providing Dial-Up access using Livingston Portmaster 3's. I bet those

RE: Dial Concentrators - TNT / APX8000 R.I.P.

2010-05-11 Thread Gregory J. Boehnlein
When I sold my business in January, we still had 4 PRI circuits that were providing Dial-Up access using Livingston Portmaster 3's. I bet those things will run for another 5 years! :) Dial Up still has a place in many areas where Broadband cannot cost-effectively reach. Better to have Dial Up than

Re: Dial Concentrators - TNT / APX8000 R.I.P.

2010-05-11 Thread Curtis Maurand
30% of all people in the US (110 million) have no access to broadband. Large areas of my state have no access to broadband because its rural (Maine). Aastra CVX (it used to be a Nortel product.) --Curtis On 5/11/2010 11:29 AM, Joe Abley wrote: On 2010-05-11, at 11:08, Leo Bicknell wrote:

Re: Dial Concentrators - TNT / APX8000 R.I.P.

2010-05-11 Thread Joe Abley
On 2010-05-11, at 11:08, Leo Bicknell wrote: > There comes a time when the old tech just doesn't make sense, even > if a small customer base still wants it. There will also no doubt continue to be many customers for whom dial is the only option. It's not long ago that I lived in such a house,

Re: Dial Concentrators - TNT / APX8000 R.I.P.

2010-05-11 Thread Leo Bicknell
In a message written on Mon, May 10, 2010 at 11:28:42AM -0500, Jerry Bonner wrote: > I share a certain amount of love for this platform dating back to Ascend, but > what am I to do now? Obviously no one is making large investments in their > dial platform, but are there any other viable alternat

Re: Dial Concentrators - TNT / APX8000 R.I.P.

2010-05-11 Thread Curtis Maurand
On 5/10/2010 6:36 PM, Mark Foster wrote: Does this not highlight a wider issue? I realise that dialup is hardly 'cutting edge' but there are providers out there with a significant number of dialup customers still on the books. Surely there's still a market for (what should be by now) a straightf

Re: Dial Concentrators - TNT / APX8000 R.I.P.

2010-05-10 Thread Justin M. Streiner
On Tue, 11 May 2010, Alastair Johnson wrote: Welcome to what telcos have been dealing with for 10 to 20 years with product lifecycles. The PSTN isn't exactly a growing market, and has lots of EOL switches, yet it continues to run. Secondary support markets, grey markets, and strategic migrat

Re: Dial Concentrators - TNT / APX8000 R.I.P.

2010-05-10 Thread Antonio Querubin
On Tue, 11 May 2010, Mark Andrews wrote: 6to4 You don't want 6to4. Even if you provide relay routers the return traffic is problematic. 6to4 also requires public IPv4 addresses and you will eventually want to share these between your customers. Providing 6to4 for dialup users is an adequat

Re: Dial Concentrators - TNT / APX8000 R.I.P.

2010-05-10 Thread Mark Andrews
In message <201005110413.o4b4disn031...@drugs.dv.isc.org>, Mark Andrews writes: > > > How are ISPs that still offer dialup going to handle dialup and IPv6? I > > > know the TNTs don't do it, and I don't think most of the old equipment > > > in use in many places does. > > > > 6to4 > > You don't

Re: Dial Concentrators - TNT / APX8000 R.I.P.

2010-05-10 Thread Mark Andrews
In message , Antonio Querubin writes: > On Mon, 10 May 2010, Chris Adams wrote: > > > How are ISPs that still offer dialup going to handle dialup and IPv6? I > > know the TNTs don't do it, and I don't think most of the old equipment > > in use in many places does. > > 6to4 You don't want 6to4

Re: Dial Concentrators - TNT / APX8000 R.I.P.

2010-05-10 Thread Alastair Johnson
Chris Adams wrote: How are ISPs that still offer dialup going to handle dialup and IPv6? I know the TNTs don't do it, and I don't think most of the old equipment in use in many places does. Most likely the customers still on dialup are not going to worry about IPv6 - if their systems even su

Re: Dial Concentrators - TNT / APX8000 R.I.P.

2010-05-10 Thread Alastair Johnson
Mark Foster wrote: Does this not highlight a wider issue? I realise that dialup is hardly 'cutting edge' but there are providers out there with a significant number of dialup customers still on the books. Surely there's still a market for (what should be by now) a straightforward, well known pie

Re: Dial Concentrators - TNT / APX8000 R.I.P.

2010-05-10 Thread Antonio Querubin
On Mon, 10 May 2010, Chris Adams wrote: How are ISPs that still offer dialup going to handle dialup and IPv6? I know the TNTs don't do it, and I don't think most of the old equipment in use in many places does. 6to4 Antonio Querubin 808-545-5282 x3003 e-mail/xmpp: t...@lava.net

Re: Dial Concentrators - TNT / APX8000 R.I.P.

2010-05-10 Thread Justin M. Streiner
On Mon, 10 May 2010, Chris Adams wrote: Once upon a time, Justin M. Streiner said: I have a small handful of AS5300s still floating around for that handful of users who can't (or won't) ditch dialup. Luckily that number is small enough that I can replace any failed parts with parts from other

Re: Dial Concentrators - TNT / APX8000 R.I.P.

2010-05-10 Thread Mark Andrews
In message <20100511002909.ga1109...@hiwaay.net>, Chris Adams writes: > How are ISPs that still offer dialup going to handle dialup and IPv6? I > know the TNTs don't do it, and I don't think most of the old equipment > in use in many places does. Just tunnel IPv6 over IPv4 and run a tunnel broke

Re: Dial Concentrators - TNT / APX8000 R.I.P.

2010-05-10 Thread Chris Adams
Once upon a time, Justin M. Streiner said: > I have a small handful of AS5300s still floating around for that handful > of users who can't (or won't) ditch dialup. Luckily that number is small > enough that I can replace any failed parts with parts from other chassis, > since the ones I have w

Re: Dial Concentrators - TNT / APX8000 R.I.P.

2010-05-10 Thread Mark Foster
Does this not highlight a wider issue? I realise that dialup is hardly 'cutting edge' but there are providers out there with a significant number of dialup customers still on the books. Surely there's still a market for (what should be by now) a straightforward, well known piece of kit? In parts

Re: Dial Concentrators - TNT / APX8000 R.I.P.

2010-05-10 Thread Anton Kapela
On May 10, 2010, at 12:28 PM, Jerry Bonner wrote: > Obviously no one is making large investments in their dial platform, but are > there any other viable alternatives out there that are actually supported? The current 'still works, has features, etc' box is as5400xm, and is terming most of a f

Re: Dial Concentrators - TNT / APX8000 R.I.P.

2010-05-10 Thread Justin M. Streiner
On Mon, 10 May 2010, Jerry Bonner wrote: I'm told by our Alcatel rep that the APX 8000 is no longer supported and that we can no longer get hardware support because they "don't have any spare parts". I share a certain amount of love for this platform dating back to Ascend, but what am I to d

Re: Dial Concentrators - TNT / APX8000 R.I.P.

2010-05-10 Thread Bill Fehring
I don't think that you can buy new support contracts for the AS5800 series anymore. http://www.cisco.com/en/US/prod/collateral/iad/ps509/ps512/end_of_life_notice_c51-463159.html -Bill On Mon, May 10, 2010 at 09:50, Scott Berkman wrote: > I think the only one under support may be the Cisco AS s

RE: Dial Concentrators - TNT / APX8000 R.I.P.

2010-05-10 Thread Scott Berkman
I think the only one under support may be the Cisco AS series (AS5800 only now?): http://www.cisco.com/en/US/products/hw/univgate/ps509/ The other platform I knew besides the TNT was the Nortel CVX but it is EOL also. -Scott -Original Message- From: Jerry Bonner [mailto:jbon...@