Re: Suppressing excess indexing

2012-09-21 Thread Andreas Koenig
Johan Vromans writes: >> But as other responses have pointed out already , there is no >> cpan-netiquette that demands to keep the number of indexed modules >> low. > > As I understood from the OP it applies to the case where > * you have a module that implements public functionality > * this mo

Re: Suppressing excess indexing

2012-09-20 Thread Johan Vromans
Andreas Koenig writes: > But as other responses have pointed out already , there is no > cpan-netiquette that demands to keep the number of indexed modules > low. As I understood from the OP it applies to the case where * you have a module that implements public functionality * this module requ

Re: Suppressing excess indexing

2012-09-20 Thread Andreas Koenig
Leon Timmermans writes: > On Wed, Sep 19, 2012 at 11:24 PM, Leon Timmermans wrote: >> If you really want to, you can disable it by inserting a newline >> between the package keyword and the name. However, I'm not really >> seeing the point of pretending your distribution is one package when >> i

Re: Suppressing excess indexing

2012-09-20 Thread David Cantrell
I was unaware that we had any support for keywords. But even if we do, a distro author's idea of what the keywords are may not match the users' or the users' expectations of how to search the cpan. If keywords exist then they might be a good *addition* to the CPAN search tools but can't replace

Re: Suppressing excess indexing

2012-09-20 Thread David Cantrell
On Wed, Sep 19, 2012 at 11:24:27PM +0200, Leon Timmermans wrote: > On Wed, Sep 19, 2012 at 9:44 PM, Geoffrey Leach wrote: > > I have a distribution (Audio::TagLib, FWIW) that has a large number of > > modules, but only the main module is of any interest to the index. What > > do I need to do in th

Re: Suppressing excess indexing

2012-09-20 Thread John M. Gamble
On Thu, September 20, 2012 9:45 am, Johan Vromans wrote: > David Cantrell writes: > >> I would say that it's actually *useful* to index them all. That way >> your dist will show up if people search for 'FLAC' (to pick just one >> example), which is probably a Good Thing. > > That would be the pur

Re: Suppressing excess indexing

2012-09-20 Thread Johan Vromans
David Cantrell writes: > I would say that it's actually *useful* to index them all. That way > your dist will show up if people search for 'FLAC' (to pick just one > example), which is probably a Good Thing. That would be the purpose of keywords. Not indexes by package name. -- Johan

Re: Suppressing excess indexing

2012-09-19 Thread Leon Timmermans
On Wed, Sep 19, 2012 at 11:24 PM, Leon Timmermans wrote: > If you really want to, you can disable it by inserting a newline > between the package keyword and the name. However, I'm not really > seeing the point of pretending your distribution is one package when > it in fact isn't. YMMV. Replied

Re: Suppressing excess indexing

2012-09-19 Thread Leon Timmermans
On Wed, Sep 19, 2012 at 9:44 PM, Geoffrey Leach wrote: > I have a distribution (Audio::TagLib, FWIW) that has a large number of > modules, but only the main module is of any interest to the index. What > do I need to do in the construction of the release to tell indexing not > to bother? If you r