Re: Issue 4274: Fix a cyclic dependency in Rest_collision (issue 193590043 by nine.fierce.ball...@gmail.com)

2015-01-27 Thread Keith OHara
On Tue, 27 Jan 2015 05:09:58 -0800, wrote: On 2015/01/27 05:21:47, Keith wrote: I discovered this when I tried to use get_property("stencil") from Rest::height while trying to fix issue 4245. It looks like some rests (whole and half rests) have two glyphs, with and without the ledger line,

Mail list addition.

2015-01-27 Thread Oliver Thompson
Hi, I've been using lilypond for a while now, and if possible, I would like to be added to the mailing list to assist users of lilypond. Seeing as my relative Neil Puttock used to be a core developer of lilypond, I thought I would try to help lilypond as much as possible. Thanks, Ollie ___

Re: strange behaviour with dotted note before gregorian music

2015-01-27 Thread Ali Cuota
James, you are right, I just wanted to answer fast between 2 appointments. Here it is Franck 2015-01-27 17:07 GMT-05:00, James Lowe : > On 27/01/15 18:25, Ali Cuota wrote: >> Here it is. > > Hardly a 'tiny' example > > http://lilypond.org/tiny-examples.html > > Can you at least get rid of the cruf

Re: strange behaviour with dotted note before gregorian music

2015-01-27 Thread Thomas Morley
2015-01-27 23:07 GMT+01:00 James Lowe : > On 27/01/15 18:25, Ali Cuota wrote: >> Here it is. > > Hardly a 'tiny' example > > http://lilypond.org/tiny-examples.html > > Can you at least get rid of the cruft that isn't anything to do with the > problem? I.e. a single file would help to determine if t

Re: Issue 2535: Staccato on stem side alignment when other articulations are present (issue 196260043 by david.nales...@gmail.com)

2015-01-27 Thread david . nalesnik
On 2015/01/27 22:00:49, lemzwerg wrote: https://codereview.appspot.com/196260043/diff/20001/input/regression/script-shift.ly File input/regression/script-shift.ly (right): https://codereview.appspot.com/196260043/diff/20001/input/regression/script-shift.ly#newcode6 input/regression/script-sh

Re: strange behaviour with dotted note before gregorian music

2015-01-27 Thread James Lowe
On 27/01/15 18:25, Ali Cuota wrote: > Here it is. Hardly a 'tiny' example http://lilypond.org/tiny-examples.html Can you at least get rid of the cruft that isn't anything to do with the problem? I.e. a single file would help to determine if the problem is to do with the 'include' function or not

Re: Issue 2535: Staccato on stem side alignment when other articulations are present (issue 196260043 by david.nales...@gmail.com)

2015-01-27 Thread lemzwerg
https://codereview.appspot.com/196260043/diff/20001/input/regression/script-shift.ly File input/regression/script-shift.ly (right): https://codereview.appspot.com/196260043/diff/20001/input/regression/script-shift.ly#newcode6 input/regression/script-shift.ly:6: means centered on the stem.) I'm

Re: Issue 2535: Staccato on stem side alignment when other articulations are present (issue 196260043 by david.nales...@gmail.com)

2015-01-27 Thread david . nalesnik
https://codereview.appspot.com/196260043/diff/20001/input/regression/script-shift.ly File input/regression/script-shift.ly (right): https://codereview.appspot.com/196260043/diff/20001/input/regression/script-shift.ly#newcode6 input/regression/script-shift.ly:6: means centered on the stem.) On 20

Re: Issue 2535: Staccato on stem side alignment when other articulations are present (issue 196260043 by david.nales...@gmail.com)

2015-01-27 Thread lemzwerg
LGTM. https://codereview.appspot.com/196260043/diff/20001/input/regression/script-shift.ly File input/regression/script-shift.ly (right): https://codereview.appspot.com/196260043/diff/20001/input/regression/script-shift.ly#newcode6 input/regression/script-shift.ly:6: means centered on the stem.

Re: strange behaviour with dotted note before gregorian music

2015-01-27 Thread Ali Cuota
Here it is. Franck 2015-01-27 12:46 GMT-05:00, James Lowe : > Hello > > On 27/01/15 16:05, Ali Cuota wrote: >> Hello again, >> >> version "2.18.0" >> I have a western-notation piece that finishes with a dotted-note a4. >> (very last note) >> then a gregorian piece. >> both comes in a book.ly with

Re: strange behaviour with dotted note before gregorian music

2015-01-27 Thread James Lowe
Hello On 27/01/15 16:05, Ali Cuota wrote: Hello again, version "2.18.0" I have a western-notation piece that finishes with a dotted-note a4. (very last note) then a gregorian piece. both comes in a book.ly with include "..." Compiling the sole gregorian is ok Compiling the book makes the gregor

Re: Issue 2535: Staccato on stem side alignment when other articulations are present (issue 196260043 by david.nales...@gmail.com)

2015-01-27 Thread david . nalesnik
On 2015/01/27 15:07:24, dak wrote: On 2015/01/27 14:37:27, david.nalesnik wrote: > What would this property be named? snap-to-column? shift-in-column? I suggest picking a name that starts in the same way as the existing property. toward-stem-shift-in-column would be unambiguous. Long, pe

strange behaviour with dotted note before gregorian music

2015-01-27 Thread Ali Cuota
Hello again, version "2.18.0" I have a western-notation piece that finishes with a dotted-note a4. (very last note) then a gregorian piece. both comes in a book.ly with include "..." Compiling the sole gregorian is ok Compiling the book makes the gregorian have dotted (augmentum) at every notes ex

Re: Issue 2535: Staccato on stem side alignment when other articulations are present (issue 196260043 by david.nales...@gmail.com)

2015-01-27 Thread dak
On 2015/01/27 14:37:27, david.nalesnik wrote: What would this property be named? snap-to-column? shift-in-column? I suggest picking a name that starts in the same way as the existing property. While I see the arguments for adding another property, I worry that in so doing there is a risk o

Re: Issue 2535: Staccato on stem side alignment when other articulations are present (issue 196260043 by david.nales...@gmail.com)

2015-01-27 Thread david . nalesnik
Eek. Sorry for overquoting. https://codereview.appspot.com/196260043/ ___ lilypond-devel mailing list lilypond-devel@gnu.org https://lists.gnu.org/mailman/listinfo/lilypond-devel

Re: Issue 2535: Staccato on stem side alignment when other articulations are present (issue 196260043 by david.nales...@gmail.com)

2015-01-27 Thread david . nalesnik
On 2015/01/27 08:50:36, dak wrote: On 2015/01/27 07:52:05, lemzwerg wrote: > On 2015/01/27 07:26:53, dak wrote: > > It seems to me like this number-pair consists of two settings that would > almost > > always be adjusted independently. Wouldn't it make more sense to make a > > separate prope

Re: Issue 2535: Staccato on stem side alignment when other articulations are present (issue 196260043 by david.nales...@gmail.com)

2015-01-27 Thread david . nalesnik
On 2015/01/27 07:32:24, dak wrote: Aaaand another thought: wouldn't it make more sense instead of having independent shifts for "with other articulations" and "without other articulations" when the articulation closest to the notehead is responsible for aligning the whole stack of articulations

Re: Issue 4274: Fix a cyclic dependency in Rest_collision (issue 193590043 by nine.fierce.ball...@gmail.com)

2015-01-27 Thread nine . fierce . ballads
On 2015/01/27 05:21:47, Keith wrote: Are you sure there is a cycle? Rest_collision does use the height of the rests to determine the height of the rests, but I do not see where calling the Rest::height() function can call Rest_collision() cyclically. Is there some LilyPond input that ca

Re: Issue 2535: Staccato on stem side alignment when other articulations are present (issue 196260043 by david.nales...@gmail.com)

2015-01-27 Thread dak
On 2015/01/27 07:52:05, lemzwerg wrote: On 2015/01/27 07:26:53, dak wrote: > It seems to me like this number-pair consists of two settings that would almost > always be adjusted independently. Wouldn't it make more sense to make a > separate property here? That way, the user would not need