Re: [FRIAM] da foist pictures of a black hole

2019-04-11 Thread Eric Smith
Hi Nick, Certainly not a dumb question, but also one that I want to avoid having turn rabbinical. So I have to be careful how I answer. I imagine I am remembering posts in which you have said something like “ALL statements are metaphors”, and in that kind of reductio, there is no distinction

[FRIAM] FVPS 2019

2019-04-11 Thread glen∈ℂ
Arg! I wish I could go to this. If any of you do, please send along some notes. 2nd Workshop on Formal Verification of Physical Systems (FVPS 2019) https://www.cicm-conference.org/2019/cicm.php?event=fvps&menu=general Theme One of the main issues behind many failing systems is the ad-hoc ve

Re: [FRIAM] da foist pictures of a black hole

2019-04-11 Thread Steven A Smith
Nick-  I think Eric provides an excellent AND thorough analysis of your question "It's a metaphor, right?" in regard to the recently documented "black hole". For your purposes, I would say that "seeing a black hole" in this case is not particularly metaphorical.  But in the spirit of FriAM (or my

Re: [FRIAM] /Topic Latent in: Latent Topics was: enough sleep?

2019-04-11 Thread glen∈ℂ
On 4/10/19 1:34 PM, Steven A Smith wrote: https://sites.google.com/site/markshirey/ideas/golden-rule-and-prisoner-s-dilemma Excellent article! Thanks. Is it actually an article by Sagan? Or a blog post by Shirey? In any case, the "Tin Rule" targets my confusion well, because it's modal, usi

Re: [FRIAM] FVPS 2019

2019-04-11 Thread Steven A Smith
Glen - It does look very interesting.   I think I've referenced THIS (inter-reality) work before: https://arxiv.org/abs/physics/0611293 as well as the Phononic quantum computing my nephew has been working on. https://www.technologyreview.com/s/428844/how-to-build-a-phononic-computer/ w

Re: [FRIAM] /Topic Latent in: Latent Topics was: enough sleep?

2019-04-11 Thread Marcus Daniels
Glen writes: "What mechanism is responsible for these patterns of expectation, given (what seems to me) a co-evolutionary milieu far from equilibrium? Is it simply Hebbian/reinforcement learning, an embodied type of (false) induction? I'm skeptical because of your (Steve) question about the u

Re: [FRIAM] /Topic Latent in: Latent Topics was: enough sleep?

2019-04-11 Thread Steven A Smith
Glen - > On 4/10/19 1:34 PM, Steven A Smith wrote: >> https://sites.google.com/site/markshirey/ideas/golden-rule-and-prisoner-s-dilemma >> > > Excellent article!  Thanks. Is it actually an article by Sagan?  Or a > blog post by Shirey? I parse it as a blog post by Shirey which is composed of 3 incl

Re: [FRIAM] /Topic Latent in: Latent Topics was: enough sleep?

2019-04-11 Thread Steven A Smith
Marcus - > Glen writes: > > "What mechanism is responsible for these patterns of expectation, given (what > seems to me) a co-evolutionary milieu far from equilibrium? Is it simply > Hebbian/reinforcement learning, an embodied type of (false) induction? I'm > skeptical because of your (Steve)

Re: [FRIAM] da foist pictures of a black hole

2019-04-11 Thread Nick Thompson
Thanks, Eric, for that answer, which was everything I asked for and much, much more. I hope you will quickly save it on your hard disk for future use. It deserves to be out in the world for others to study on. I certainly will try and get the home congregation to work it over, in the future.

Re: [FRIAM] /Topic Latent in: Latent Topics was: enough sleep?

2019-04-11 Thread Marcus Daniels
Steve writes: < It seems like an elaboration of "constraint provides form"? > Here I'll admit I just have no interest in games, puzzles, and most sports. Just what IS the point? I think it is the same kind of psychology at work: Let's create some artificial thing that can be mastered or at l

Re: [FRIAM] /Topic Latent in: Latent Topics was: enough sleep?

2019-04-11 Thread uǝlƃ ☣
On 4/11/19 10:08 AM, Marcus Daniels wrote: > What I'm pitching here is not to extend identity, but to annihilate it. Can we, though? In the conversation about playing roles instead of simply changing topics of conversation, there seemed to be quite a bit of push back in the sense of "authentic

Re: [FRIAM] /Topic Latent in: Latent Topics was: enough sleep?

2019-04-11 Thread Nick Thompson
Wait, Marcus, wait! Hang on, there! Didn't you just assert an identity? Nick Nicholas S. Thompson Emeritus Professor of Psychology and Biology Clark University http://home.earthlink.net/~nickthompson/naturaldesigns/ -Original Message- From: Friam [mailto:friam-boun...@redfish.com] O

Re: [FRIAM] /Topic Latent in: Latent Topics was: enough sleep?

2019-04-11 Thread Marcus Daniels
I'm not sure what you mean. In most programming languages there are different kinds of comparison operators. For example, Common Lisp has EQ which compares identity, EQL which compares values, EQUAL which checks for isomorphic objects, and EQUALP which is recursive.By avoiding use of EQ

Re: [FRIAM] /Topic Latent in: Latent Topics was: enough sleep?

2019-04-11 Thread Steven A Smith
Marcus - > Steve writes: > > < It seems like an elaboration of "constraint provides form"? > > > Here I'll admit I just have no interest in games, puzzles, and most sports. > Just what IS the point? > I think it is the same kind of psychology at work: Let's create some > artificial thing that

Re: [FRIAM] /Topic Latent in: Latent Topics was: enough sleep?

2019-04-11 Thread Marcus Daniels
Steve writes: < What little Buddhist/Meditation affinity/practice I have suggests that it is an illusion which on a good day is fully ignored ("but by whom?" the paradox asks). To the extent that *most* everyone I know presents to me (or I apprehend them as such) as an ego-centric i

Re: [FRIAM] /Topic Latent in: Latent Topics was: enough sleep?

2019-04-11 Thread uǝlƃ ☣
What you seem to be describing is a kind of social "flow", where some say the ego disappears in the midst of it. Google presented this: Optimal Experience and Optimal Identity: A Multinational Study of the Associations Between Flow and Social Identity https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.33

Re: [FRIAM] /Topic Latent in: Latent Topics was: enough sleep?

2019-04-11 Thread Marcus Daniels
Here is an example. It's come up in different ways over the years and I always find it strange. I recently was ask to fill in a form where I state what my role on project is. The project is not well defined and much should be debated IMO. But there is desire to get on with the business o

Re: [FRIAM] /Topic Latent in: Latent Topics was: enough sleep?

2019-04-11 Thread uǝlƃ ☣
Hm. One thing that's not addressed well in that paper (as far as I know, since all I did was skim ... and I'm completely ignorant of the entire domain) is identity fluidity. The seem to talk about the strength of one's feelings of belonging (or get-alonging, if we translate to your hunger for

Re: [FRIAM] /Topic Latent in: Latent Topics was: enough sleep?

2019-04-11 Thread Marcus Daniels
Glen writes: "Just try to do the work! Who cares what you think about your self?" Uh huh. The right way to think is What Needs To Get Done, not whether you get github stars to show you did it in a day or a month, or that it shows any sort of consistency on your CV. No one gives a damn. Re

[FRIAM] Thorstein Veblen?

2019-04-11 Thread uǝlƃ ☣
I feel certain I've seen that name before, maybe in the citations for reports on the models of evolutionary economics I once worked on? I don't know. But now I *must* read a little deeper. Tomgram: Ann Jones, Our Veblen Momen https://www.tomdispatch.com/blog/176550/ > Of course, Veblen, who

Re: [FRIAM] /Topic Latent in: Latent Topics was: enough sleep?

2019-04-11 Thread Steven A Smith
Marcus - > Among engineers, especially young ones, one way the ego-centric individual > presents herself is via Not Invented Here (NIH). She simply cannot imagine > studying and using another work.The tribe permits it so long as the tribe > can be impermeable to criticism and that they can

Re: [FRIAM] /Topic Latent in: Latent Topics was: enough sleep?

2019-04-11 Thread Steven A Smith
Glen - I (think I) experience identity-fluidity through both the "group flow" referenced in the article and what seems to be nothing more than good old fashioned "empathy".   In "group flow" it is as if the team/group becomes part of my extended self.  This may reflect some narcissism on my part,

Re: [FRIAM] /Topic Latent in: Latent Topics was: enough sleep?

2019-04-11 Thread Marcus Daniels
Steve writes: < What Marcus references as "gelling" and "need for social order" strikes me as superficial goals which are emergent properties, not sufficient pre-conditions. My experience with overly formal organizations is that they tend to try to enforce those things, losing track

Re: [FRIAM] /Topic Latent in: Latent Topics was: enough sleep?

2019-04-11 Thread Marcus Daniels
Glen writes: "Do any of you psych people care to provide distinguishing definitions for a lazy dilettante like me?" I find this kind of evidence unsatisfactory.How people act as individuals or in groups says nothing about how an AI might function as individuals or in groups. It's merel