Re: [Ekiga-list] BT HomeHub blocking UDP 5060

2013-09-10 Thread Stuart Gathman
On 09/10/2013 03:28 PM, David Ford wrote: If there is no ideal solution - then perhaps a bad solution is the best thing - pop the window up may not be elegant but it is the one thing that does actually work. What we have how is already a decent solution for broken notifiers. Just click on the "

Re: [Ekiga-list] BT HomeHub blocking UDP 5060

2013-09-10 Thread Eugen Dedu
On 10/09/13 18:45, Mark Carroll wrote: Eugen Dedu writes: You are right: Ekiga does the right job, but notification programs are sometimes bad (do not show long strings), or notification server is bad (says it supports buttons, but it does not). So your request (to always show the call window

Re: [Ekiga-list] BT HomeHub blocking UDP 5060

2013-09-10 Thread Stuart Gathman
On 09/10/2013 04:20 PM, Eugen Dedu wrote: On 10/09/13 21:54, Stuart Gathman wrote: On 09/10/2013 03:28 PM, David Ford wrote: If there is no ideal solution - then perhaps a bad solution is the best thing - pop the window up may not be elegant but it is the one thing that does actually work. Wha

Re: [Ekiga-list] BT HomeHub blocking UDP 5060

2013-09-10 Thread Eugen Dedu
On 10/09/13 21:54, Stuart Gathman wrote: On 09/10/2013 03:28 PM, David Ford wrote: If there is no ideal solution - then perhaps a bad solution is the best thing - pop the window up may not be elegant but it is the one thing that does actually work. What we have how is already a decent solution

Re: [Ekiga-list] BT HomeHub blocking UDP 5060

2013-09-10 Thread David Ford
I'll give it a try David On 10 September 2013 20:54, Stuart Gathman wrote: > On 09/10/2013 03:28 PM, David Ford wrote: > >> If there is no ideal solution - then perhaps a bad solution is the best >> thing - pop the window up may not be elegant but it is the one thing that >> does actually work.

Re: [Ekiga-list] BT HomeHub blocking UDP 5060

2013-09-10 Thread David Ford
If there is no ideal solution - then perhaps a bad solution is the best thing - pop the window up may not be elegant but it is the one thing that does actually work. David On 10 September 2013 18:56, Eugen Dedu wrote: > On 10/09/13 18:45, Mark Carroll wrote: > >> Eugen Dedu >> > >> writes: >> >

Re: [Ekiga-list] BT HomeHub blocking UDP 5060

2013-09-10 Thread Eugen Dedu
On 10/09/13 00:23, Stuart Gathman wrote: On 09/08/2013 05:06 PM, Mark Carroll wrote: Stuart Gathman writes: Yes, this still happens to me. The problem is actually with the Desktop environment, not with Ekiga (other than refusing to provide an alternative to broken notifiers). As I'm using a

Re: [Ekiga-list] BT HomeHub blocking UDP 5060

2013-09-10 Thread Mark Carroll
Eugen Dedu writes: > You are right: Ekiga does the right job, but notification programs are > sometimes bad (do not show long strings), or notification server is bad > (says it supports buttons, but it does not). So your request (to always > show the call window) is good, I do not know what t

Re: [Ekiga-list] BT HomeHub blocking UDP 5060

2013-09-10 Thread Eugen Dedu
On 07/09/13 18:34, Mark Carroll wrote: Eugen Dedu writes: An idea is to let registration be made even if it reports symmetric nat. In ekiga 4.0.1, in file lib/engine/components/opal/opal-call-manager.cpp, change at line 822: if (result == PSTUNClient::SymmetricNat || result

Re: [Ekiga-list] BT HomeHub blocking UDP 5060

2013-09-09 Thread Stuart Gathman
On 09/08/2013 05:06 PM, Mark Carroll wrote: Stuart Gathman writes: Yes, this still happens to me. The problem is actually with the Desktop environment, not with Ekiga (other than refusing to provide an alternative to broken notifiers). As I'm using a lightweight twm derivative, I am not sure

Re: [Ekiga-list] BT HomeHub blocking UDP 5060

2013-09-08 Thread Mark Carroll
Stuart Gathman writes: > Yes, this still happens to me. The problem is actually with the Desktop > environment, not with Ekiga (other than refusing to provide an > alternative to broken notifiers). As I'm using a lightweight twm derivative, I am not sure I exactly have a "Desktop environment"

Re: [Ekiga-list] BT HomeHub blocking UDP 5060

2013-09-08 Thread Stuart Gathman
On 09/07/2013 12:36 PM, Mark Carroll wrote: Oh, but I should add -- with Ekiga 4.0.1 at the receiving end, I still see the issue where for an incoming call nothing came up to let me pick it up, it just told me afterward it had missed the call. Downgrading to Ekiga 3.2.7 fixes that one. (Linux, wi

Re: [Ekiga-list] BT HomeHub blocking UDP 5060

2013-09-08 Thread Mark Carroll
Eugen Dedu writes: > Be sure that what you wrote is true, i.e. test for several executions of > ekiga. Ha, now I am getting the receiving call window just fine in 4.0.1. I am playing around a bit with what other system libraries are installed but that's probably irrelevant; if I see the problem

Re: [Ekiga-list] BT HomeHub blocking UDP 5060

2013-09-07 Thread Mark Carroll
Eugen Dedu writes: > On 07/09/13 18:36, Mark Carroll wrote: >> Oh, but I should add -- with Ekiga 4.0.1 at the receiving end, I still >> see the issue where for an incoming call nothing came up to let me pick >> it up, it just told me afterward it had missed the call. Downgrading to >> Ekiga 3.2.

Re: [Ekiga-list] BT HomeHub blocking UDP 5060

2013-09-07 Thread Eugen Dedu
On 07/09/13 18:36, Mark Carroll wrote: Oh, but I should add -- with Ekiga 4.0.1 at the receiving end, I still see the issue where for an incoming call nothing came up to let me pick it up, it just told me afterward it had missed the call. Downgrading to Ekiga 3.2.7 fixes that one. (Linux, with ct

Re: [Ekiga-list] BT HomeHub blocking UDP 5060

2013-09-07 Thread Mark Carroll
Oh, but I should add -- with Ekiga 4.0.1 at the receiving end, I still see the issue where for an incoming call nothing came up to let me pick it up, it just told me afterward it had missed the call. Downgrading to Ekiga 3.2.7 fixes that one. (Linux, with ctwm window manager.) -- Mark

Re: [Ekiga-list] BT HomeHub blocking UDP 5060

2013-09-07 Thread Mark Carroll
Eugen Dedu writes: > An idea is to let registration be made even if it reports symmetric nat. > In ekiga 4.0.1, in file > lib/engine/components/opal/opal-call-manager.cpp, change at line 822: > > if (result == PSTUNClient::SymmetricNat > || result == PSTUNClient::BlockedNat >

Re: [Ekiga-list] BT HomeHub blocking UDP 5060

2013-09-07 Thread Mark Carroll
Thank you. I couldn't find any telnet access and in looking at its configuration backup I don't recognize the kind of file at all. Among the binary code in the file, some of the earliest strings are, THENC CANT-2BT Home Hub 2.0A 8.1.H.U (so, model number, firmware version), but that's about as go

Re: [Ekiga-list] BT HomeHub blocking UDP 5060

2013-09-07 Thread gegetel
This *could* be useful to get a complete firmware, but be very careful! http://www.josephn.net/unlocking_bt_home_hub ___ ekiga-list mailing list ekiga-list@gnome.org https://mail.gnome.org/mailman/listinfo/ekiga-list

Re: [Ekiga-list] BT HomeHub blocking UDP 5060

2013-09-07 Thread gegetel
Le 01/09/2013 19:05, *Mark Carroll* wrote: I am having trouble with ekiga not registering when behind a BT Home Hub running software version 8.1.H.U (Type A) If BT means British Telecom, perhaps your "BT Home Hub" is really a Technicolor/Thomson modem ? This kind of hardware needs specific set

Re: [Ekiga-list] BT HomeHub blocking UDP 5060

2013-09-06 Thread Eugen Dedu
On 06/09/13 13:10, Mark Carroll wrote: Eugen Dedu writes: (snip) Are 5063 to 5060 blocked too or not? All of UDP 5000 - 5100 are forwarded okay except for 5060. (snip) So a good idea is to make ekiga use a port different than 5060, as written in previous e-mail. Alas, it still fails if I

Re: [Ekiga-list] BT HomeHub blocking UDP 5060

2013-09-06 Thread Mark Carroll
Eugen Dedu writes: (snip) > Are 5063 to 5060 blocked too or not? All of UDP 5000 - 5100 are forwarded okay except for 5060. (snip) > So a good idea is to make ekiga use a port different than 5060, as > written in previous e-mail. Alas, it still fails if I try 5050, -d 4 at http://pastebin.com/

Re: [Ekiga-list] BT HomeHub blocking UDP 5060

2013-09-06 Thread Eugen Dedu
On 01/09/13 19:05, Mark Carroll wrote: I am having trouble with ekiga not registering when behind a BT Home Hub running software version 8.1.H.U (Type A), whether or not I enable network detection in the preferences. The -d 4 log is pasted at http://pastebin.com/bd6kAWgp Both logs report symmet

Re: [Ekiga-list] BT HomeHub blocking UDP 5060

2013-09-06 Thread Eugen Dedu
On 05/09/13 21:42, gegetel wrote: Le 01/09/2013 19:05, *Mark Carroll* wrote: Is it possible to use Ekiga, at least to initiate SIP calls, if it is behind NAT that won't forward 5060? Using gconf-editor (apps > ekiga > protocols > sip), you can set listen_port = 5061 and place and receive SIP

Re: [Ekiga-list] BT HomeHub blocking UDP 5060

2013-09-05 Thread gegetel
Le 01/09/2013 19:05, *Mark Carroll* wrote: Is it possible to use Ekiga, at least to initiate SIP calls, if it is behind NAT that won't forward 5060? Using gconf-editor (apps > ekiga > protocols > sip), you can set listen_port = 5061 and place and receive SIP calls as well. :-) _

Re: [Ekiga-list] BT HomeHub blocking UDP 5060

2013-09-05 Thread Mark Carroll
Obvious followup, though: if the ISP does firewall UDP 5060 upstream, then is there any hope? -- Mark ___ ekiga-list mailing list ekiga-list@gnome.org https://mail.gnome.org/mailman/listinfo/ekiga-list

Re: [Ekiga-list] BT HomeHub blocking UDP 5060

2013-09-05 Thread Mark Carroll
Stuart Gathman writes: > You haven't established that the device is to blame. It could be your > ISP blocking port 5060 (as some have infamously been know to do to > promote their own VOIP solutions). True. The device does support incoming 5060 for people who use the ISP's VoIP service; I don

Re: [Ekiga-list] BT HomeHub blocking UDP 5060

2013-09-05 Thread Stuart Gathman
On 09/01/2013 01:05 PM, Mark Carroll wrote: I am having trouble with ekiga not registering when behind a BT Home Hub running software version 8.1.H.U (Type A), whether or not I enable network detection in the preferences. The -d 4 log is pasted at http://pastebin.com/bd6kAWgp In probing the port

Re: [Ekiga-list] BT HomeHub blocking UDP 5060

2013-09-05 Thread Mark Carroll
Still no luck, latest log in http://pastebin.com/fnmF8CY0 where I tried configuring SIP to listen on 5050 instead: I hoped to be able to initiate calls, but I can't even register with ekiga.net. Basically, is it possible at all to use ekiga from behind NAT if UDP 5060 is blocked? (I have all the o