Re: Increasing the platform meeting's relevance for engineers

2013-04-24 Thread Doug Turner
I think if we need to find reasons to keep a meeting relevant, we need to kill the meeting. Lawrence, you should just discontinue the meeting for a few weeks and see if we really need it. I bet we wont. I would much rather see us spend the time to curate what's important -- what platform peo

Re: Rethinking the amount of system JS we use in Gecko on B2G

2013-04-24 Thread Caspy7
I'm not a developer and so apologize if my understanding is oversimplified or naive. I had been under the impression that C++ (previously) was not being used at all, apart from Gecko itself, for security and stability reasons. Perhaps I am mistaken or simply misunderstand the structures discuss

Re: Some data on mozilla-inbound

2013-04-24 Thread Phil Ringnalda
On 4/24/13 9:50 PM, Ehsan Akhgari wrote: > No. But that's not what I was talking about. Whether something lands > directly on try is a judgement call, and some people may be better at it > than others. As someone who has stopped using try server as a rule > (because of the excessive wait times t

Re: Some data on mozilla-inbound

2013-04-24 Thread Phil Ringnalda
On 4/22/13 12:54 PM, Kartikaya Gupta wrote: > I looked at all the build.json files [4] from the 6th of April to the > 17th of April and pulled out all the jobs that corresponding to the > "push" changesets in my range above. For this set of 553 changesets, > there were 500 (exactly!) distinct "buil

Re: Some data on mozilla-inbound

2013-04-24 Thread Justin Lebar
> One idea might be to give developers feedback on the consequences of a > particular push, e.g. the AWS cost, a proxy for "time during which > developers couldn't push" or some other measurable metric. Right now > each push probably "feels" as "expensive" as every other. For tryserver, I propose

Re: Some data on mozilla-inbound

2013-04-24 Thread Ehsan Akhgari
On 2013-04-25 1:02 AM, David Ascher wrote: The messaging around this should not be to tell people "always test on try". It should be to help them figure out how to make better judgement calls on this. This is a skill that people develop and are not born with, and without data i

Re: Increasing the platform meeting's relevance for engineers

2013-04-24 Thread Ehsan Akhgari
I can definitely tell you what I liked and disliked about these meetings, and why I stopped going to them. * Too many status updates. Putting the status updates in the wiki is great. Reading over them when a lot of people are listening synchronously is not. The KISS rule needs to be followe

Re: Increasing the platform meeting's relevance for engineers

2013-04-24 Thread Ehsan Akhgari
On 2013-04-24 3:35 PM, Benjamin Smedberg wrote: On 4/24/2013 3:13 PM, Justin Lebar wrote: and last time I checked there's no way to get notified when a meeting's notes are up (via RSS or e-mail or whatever). https://blog.mozilla.org/meeting-notes/archives/tag/mozillaplatform and it shows up on

Re: Some data on mozilla-inbound

2013-04-24 Thread David Ascher
> The messaging around this should not be to tell people "always test on > try". It should be to help them figure out how to make better judgement > calls on this. This is a skill that people develop and are not born with, > and without data it's hard an an individual to judge how good I'm at tha

Re: Some data on mozilla-inbound

2013-04-24 Thread Ehsan Akhgari
On 2013-04-24 9:14 AM, Ben Hearsum wrote: On 04/23/13 10:21 PM, Kartikaya Gupta wrote: On 13-04-23 19:21 , Nicholas Nethercote wrote: - The 'inbound was closed for 15.3068% of the total time due to "bustage"' number is an underestimate, in one sense. When inbound is closed at 10am California t

Re: Some data on mozilla-inbound

2013-04-24 Thread Ehsan Akhgari
On 2013-04-23 1:17 PM, Ed Morley wrote: On 23/04/2013 17:28, Kartikaya Gupta wrote: On 13-04-23 00:39 , Ehsan Akhgari wrote: How hard would it be to gather a list of the total number of patches being backed out plus the amount of time that we spent building/testing those, hopefully in a style s

Re: Some data on mozilla-inbound

2013-04-24 Thread Ehsan Akhgari
On 2013-04-23 12:05 PM, Justin Lebar wrote: The ratio of things landed on inbound which turn out to busted is really worrying On the one hand, we're told not to push to try too much, because that wastes resources. On the other hand, we're told not to burn m-i, because that wastes resources.

Re: Increasing the platform meeting's relevance for engineers

2013-04-24 Thread Bobby Holley
+1 to meeting notes being mailed out or on a feed somewhere. I generally avoid big meetings like the plague because the density of discussion that I'm interested in is too low to warrant my full attention, and I'm not great at context-switching to and from my own work either. I usually just sit th

Re: Increasing the platform meeting's relevance for engineers

2013-04-24 Thread Benjamin Smedberg
On 4/24/2013 3:13 PM, Justin Lebar wrote: and last time I checked there's no way to get notified when a meeting's notes are up (via RSS or e-mail or whatever). https://blog.mozilla.org/meeting-notes/archives/tag/mozillaplatform and it shows up on the "projects" planet as well. --BDS _

Re: Increasing the platform meeting's relevance for engineers

2013-04-24 Thread Lawrence Mandel
- Original Message - > One thing I love about the MoCo meetings is that if I don't go, I > don't miss anything except the chance to ask questions: mbrubeck &co > create detailed minutes (really, transcripts) of every meeting, which > I can read on my schedule. He then e-mails the transcr

Re: Increasing the platform meeting's relevance for engineers

2013-04-24 Thread Justin Lebar
One thing I love about the MoCo meetings is that if I don't go, I don't miss anything except the chance to ask questions: mbrubeck &co create detailed minutes (really, transcripts) of every meeting, which I can read on my schedule. He then e-mails the transcript out to everyone, so I don't even ha

Increasing the platform meeting's relevance for engineers

2013-04-24 Thread Lawrence Mandel
tl;dr I would like to make the platform meeting more relevant for engineers. I have already made some changes (see below) and am interested in your feedback on what you would like to get out of this meeting. If you don't currently attend, what would make this meeting relevant for you? --- Sinc

Re: Automatic tree clobbering is coming

2013-04-24 Thread Ed Morley
On 23 April 2013 19:59:28, Chris Lord wrote: Having just read up the replies, it seems that it's generally agreed that this would be better as an opt-in feature. Is anyone tasked to make it such? Is there a bug I can follow for it? Bug 863091 (I've attached a patch, which will land soon). Ed _

Turning off Fedora 12 Talos tests on mozilla-central

2013-04-24 Thread Rail Aliiev
Hi, We are going to turn off Fedora 12 based Talos tests on mozilla-central, mozilla-inbound and project branches and run them on Ubuntu 12.04 platform this Thursday. This includes both 32 and 64-bit platforms and this work is tracked in Bug 863903 [1]. We have been using Fedora and Ubuntu in par

Re: Some data on mozilla-inbound

2013-04-24 Thread Ben Hearsum
On 04/23/13 10:21 PM, Kartikaya Gupta wrote: > On 13-04-23 19:21 , Nicholas Nethercote wrote: >> - The 'inbound was closed for 15.3068% of the total time due to >> "bustage"' number is an underestimate, in one sense. When inbound is >> closed at 10am California time, it's a lot more inconvenient t