Re: Jakarta EE migration

2024-11-28 Thread Lari Hotari
https://github.com/apache/pulsar/pull/23647 addresses the pulsar-client (shaded), pulsar-client-admin (shaded and pulsar-client-all (shaded) shading issues where javax.annotation was exposed, https://github.com/apache/pulsar/issues/21297 . The issues have been resolved by migrating some annotat

Re: Jakarta EE migration

2024-11-07 Thread Lari Hotari
On Thu, 7 Nov 2024 at 07:38, Christian Ortlepp wrote: > > > Semantic versioning is followed. > > Even if no Jakarta Interfaces/Annotations are part of Pulsars public > API, switching to jakarta can (and probably will) mess with the > dependency resolution of everybody who uses the client. So I do

Re: Jakarta EE migration

2024-11-06 Thread Christian Ortlepp
> Semantic versioning is followed. Even if no Jakarta Interfaces/Annotations are part of Pulsars public API, switching to jakarta can (and probably will) mess with the dependency resolution of everybody who uses the client. So I do think this is a breaking change, even if no javax/jakarta inte

Re: Jakarta EE migration

2024-11-06 Thread Christian Ortlepp
Just curious to know your requirements. Are you primarily interested in Jakarta dependencies in the Pulsar Java client or do you have requirements for the broker / server side libraries of Pulsar. What is your primary motivation? Explaining that could help take your explicit requirements into cons

Re: Jakarta EE migration

2024-11-06 Thread Lari Hotari
On Wed, 6 Nov 2024 at 12:06, Christian Ortlepp wrote: > We don't really care at all about what the broker / server side > libraries do, since we don't have to integrate those with our application. Thanks, that clarifies the requirement. > > The current target schedule is Pulsar 4.1 which is due

Re: Jakarta EE migration

2024-11-06 Thread Lari Hotari
On Wed, 6 Nov 2024 at 09:35, Christian Ortlepp wrote: > > Thank you for the information and sorry for the late reply, I had to > discuss this with some of my colleagues first. Currently we are still > working on migrating some other libraries to jakarta that have a higher > priority for our project

Re: Jakarta EE migration

2024-11-06 Thread Christian Ortlepp
sted in contributing to the Jetty 12 and Jakarta EE migration? -Lari On Mon, 28 Oct 2024 at 18:03, Christian Ortlepp wrote: Hi, are there any plans for pulsar to migrate to Jakarta EE? Is any work going on in this regard? If not, are there any concrete reasons for this (apart from nobody did

Re: Jakarta EE migration

2024-10-30 Thread Lari Hotari
;t happen. This is the last update: https://lists.apache.org/thread/mkxw56bt8jdf5b1zq1gdwvy50xgrdj30 . Would you be interested in contributing to the Jetty 12 and Jakarta EE migration? -Lari On Mon, 28 Oct 2024 at 18:03, Christian Ortlepp wrote: > > Hi, > > are there any plans for p

Jakarta EE migration

2024-10-28 Thread Christian Ortlepp
Hi, are there any plans for pulsar to migrate to Jakarta EE? Is any work going on in this regard? If not, are there any concrete reasons for this (apart from nobody did it yet) and would you be open to merging something in this regard? Are there any particular pain-points that one should expe