Re: [DISCUSS] Splitting User support mailing list

2021-03-02 Thread Henry Saputra
-1 for splitting user list to areas in Flink. As Robert and others have chimed in, we could have separate user list for sub projects in Flink, like statefun - Henry On Tue, Mar 2, 2021, 11:27 AM Roman Khachatryan wrote: > Thanks Robert, > > That's a good idea, let's revisit it later. > > Regar

Re: [DISCUSS] Splitting User support mailing list

2021-03-02 Thread Roman Khachatryan
Thanks Robert, That's a good idea, let's revisit it later. Regards, Roman On Tue, Mar 2, 2021 at 3:40 PM Robert Metzger wrote: > Thanks a lot for bringing up this idea Roman! > > After reading the initial proposal, I quite liked the idea, because it > makes our life easier: We can only monito

Re: [DISCUSS] Splitting User support mailing list

2021-03-02 Thread Robert Metzger
Thanks a lot for bringing up this idea Roman! After reading the initial proposal, I quite liked the idea, because it makes our life easier: We can only monitor lists relevant for the topics we are working on (I have to admit that I usually skip all questions that seem to be related to SQL or State

Re: [DISCUSS] Splitting User support mailing list

2021-03-01 Thread Roman Khachatryan
@tzuli...@apache.org > instead of splitting into “sub-lists”, we should simply have dedicated “sub-topic maintainers” assigned. I think this could also work, but some mails may fall between the filters. @i...@ververica.com I guess the previous decision about StateFun ML was made in a bit differe

Re: [DISCUSS] Splitting User support mailing list

2021-03-01 Thread Igal Shilman
Hi Roman, Regarding StateFun having a separate mailing list, I'm ok with it going either-way, however when we first contributed the project there was already a discussion about having a separate mailing list for StateFun [1] and the feedback was having StateFun be part of the regular mailing list.

Re: [DISCUSS] Splitting User support mailing list

2021-03-01 Thread Tzu-Li (Gordon) Tai
Hi, I feel that the issues Roman has pointed out so far, is less a problem of all topics (SQL / PyFlink / StateFun) being on the same list, and more a problem that we are missing dedicated groups of “user support shepherds” who are specifically responsible for individual topics on a day-to-day bas

Re: [DISCUSS] Splitting User support mailing list

2021-03-01 Thread Roman Khachatryan
Thanks for your replies! @Konstantin Knauf > Why do you think the quality and speed of answers would improve with dedicated lists? If there is a question on something that you are not an expert in; then you either have to - pull in someone who is more experienced in it (more time on hops, esp. if

Re: [DISCUSS] Splitting User support mailing list

2021-03-01 Thread Dawid Wysakowicz
As others I'd also rather be -1 on splitting (even splitting out the statefun). Personally I don't find it problematic. I often find the subjects quite descriptive, they often include tags or mention which API they refer to. If they don't I am quite sure having separate sub-lists would not help in

Re: [DISCUSS] Splitting User support mailing list

2021-03-01 Thread Timo Walther
I would vote -0 here. I fear that we are creating potential silos where a team doesn't know what is going on in the other teams. Regards, Timo On 01.03.21 10:47, Jark Wu wrote: I also have some concerns about splitting python and sql. Because I have seen some SQL questions users reported bu

Re: [DISCUSS] Splitting User support mailing list

2021-03-01 Thread Jark Wu
I also have some concerns about splitting python and sql. Because I have seen some SQL questions users reported but is related to deployment or state backend. Best, Jark On Mon, 1 Mar 2021 at 17:15, Konstantin Knauf wrote: > Hi Roman, > > I slightly +1 for a list dedicated to Statefun users, bu

Re: [DISCUSS] Splitting User support mailing list

2021-03-01 Thread Konstantin Knauf
Hi Roman, I slightly +1 for a list dedicated to Statefun users, but -1 for splitting up the rest. I think there are still a lot of crosscutting concerns between Python, DataStream, Table API and SQL where users of another API can also help out, too. It also requires users to think about which list

Re: [DISCUSS] Splitting User support mailing list

2021-03-01 Thread xiao...@ysstech.com
Hi Roman, This is a very good idea. I will look forward to the official setting up "sub-lists" as soon as possible and sharing development experience and problems with friends in a certain field. Regards, yue xiao...@ysstech.com From: Roman Khachatryan Date: 2021-03-01 16:48 To: dev Subjec