Re: [DISCUSS][Swift] repo for swift similar to arrow-rs

2023-10-14 Thread Andrew Lamb
gt; https://lists.apache.org/thread/9hy387r8hvfrtnqdvgyszj3mf53mdr96 > > * Future of the Julia arrow implementation > > https://github.com/apache/arrow-julia/issues/284 > > > > > > Thanks, > > -- > > kou > > > > In > > < > mn2pr02m

Re: [DISCUSS][Swift] repo for swift similar to arrow-rs

2023-10-11 Thread Alva Bandy
org/thread/w3dr1vlt9115r3x9m7bprmo4zpnog483 > * [DISCUSS][Julia] How to restart at apache/arrow-julia? > https://lists.apache.org/thread/9hy387r8hvfrtnqdvgyszj3mf53mdr96 > * Future of the Julia arrow implementation > https://github.com/apache/arrow-julia/issues/284 > > > T

Re: [DISCUSS][Swift] repo for swift similar to arrow-rs

2023-10-11 Thread Alva Bandy
Hi Antoine, I took a look around and it is possible to use Arrow Rust libraries. It looks like a C api would need to be created for the Rust lib (looks like the same process is required to leverage Rust from C++ as well). Thank you, Alva Bandy > On Oct 11, 2023, at 3:45 AM, Antoine Pitrou wr

Re: [DISCUSS][Swift] repo for swift similar to arrow-rs

2023-10-11 Thread Alva Bandy
Hi, Thank you feedback and info: Dewey, Jacob and David! This request comes from an ask from potential contributors. I think it is a valid and I definitely see Dewey’s point in regards to making contributing less intimidating. :) I am planning on adding the package to Swift Package Index

Re: [DISCUSS][Swift] repo for swift similar to arrow-rs

2023-10-11 Thread Antoine Pitrou
Is Arrow C++ the only reusable codebase for that or could the work be based on e.g. Arrow Rust instead? I don't know the interoperability story of the Swift language, so there might be something that favors C++ here. Regards Antoine. Le 11/10/2023 à 02:43, David Li a écrit : I'm -0 on

Re: [DISCUSS][Swift] repo for swift similar to arrow-rs

2023-10-10 Thread Sutou Kouhei
arrow implementation https://github.com/apache/arrow-julia/issues/284 Thanks, -- kou In "[DISCUSS][Swift] repo for swift similar to arrow-rs" on Mon, 9 Oct 2023 20:26:53 +, Alva Bandy wrote: > Hi, > > I would like to request a repo for Arrow Swift (similar to arrow

Re: [DISCUSS][Swift] repo for swift similar to arrow-rs

2023-10-10 Thread David Li
I'm -0 on this without more reasoning. I don't think a large download is a compelling reason to split the repo, and being in the same repo doesn't mean you have to take a dependency on the C++ implementation. (Plus, unless there is enough of a community to replicate all the work done for C++ I s

Re: [DISCUSS][Swift] repo for swift similar to arrow-rs

2023-10-10 Thread Jacob Wujciak-Jens
+1 on Dewey's sentiment. With regards to technicalities: - a PMC member can create the repo via ASF's gitbox (I assume 'arrow-swift'?) - the repo then needs to be configured using the '.asf.yaml' - which merge styles are allowed - branch protection rules - to which ml should notifications be

Re: [DISCUSS][Swift] repo for swift similar to arrow-rs

2023-10-10 Thread Dewey Dunnington
Hi Alva, I would encourage you to do whatever will make life more pleasant for you and other contributors to the Swift Arrow implementation. I have found development of an Arrow subproject (nanoarrow) in a separate repository very pleasant. While I don't run integration tests there, it's not becau

Re: [DISCUSS][Swift] repo for swift similar to arrow-rs

2023-10-10 Thread Antoine Pitrou
Hi Alva, I'll let others give their opinions on the repo. Regards Antoine. Le 10/10/2023 à 19:25, Alva Bandy a écrit : Hi Antoine, Thanks for the reply. It would be great to get the Swift implementation added to the integration test. I have a task for adding the C Data Interface and I

RE: Re: [DISCUSS][Swift] repo for swift similar to arrow-rs

2023-10-10 Thread Alva Bandy
Hi Antoine, Thanks for the reply. It would be great to get the Swift implementation added to the integration test. I have a task for adding the C Data Interface and I will work on getting the integration test running for Swift after that task. Can we move forward with setting up the repo a

Re: [DISCUSS][Swift] repo for swift similar to arrow-rs

2023-10-10 Thread Antoine Pitrou
Hello Alva, This is a reasonable request, but it might come with its own drawbacks as well. One significant drawback is that adding the Swift implementation to the cross-implementation integration tests will be slightly more complicated. It is very important that all Arrow implementations a

[DISCUSS][Swift] repo for swift similar to arrow-rs

2023-10-09 Thread Alva Bandy
Hi, I would like to request a repo for Arrow Swift (similar to arrow-rs). Swift arrow is currently fully Swift and doesn't leverage the C++ libraries. One of the goals of Arrow Swift was to provide a fully Swift impl and splitting them now would help ensure that Swift Arrow stays on this path.