I'm using Postfix's XCLIENT to synthesize/inject a test email into my
postfix->filter/milter->delivery chain.
I'd like to verify that my XCLIENT usage isn't the cause of the delivery
failure I see below ...
@ this postfix instance, mail flows as
-> postscreen (@ IP = 203.0.113.1)
|
internal smptd
|
spf policy engine (no reject; check + header only)
|
preQ milters: opendkim, opendmarc, clamav-milter, spamassassin-milter
|
lmtp -> dovecot
I've no inbound/outbound issues.
Except ...
... from a single source -- @intuit.com. it's FAIL'ing @ opendmarc checks.
I've online-checked SPF/DMARC records for 'intuit.com'; all _seems_ to be ok.
I've cranked up opendmarc logging level to
MilterDebug 5
with that, on failed attempt, I see only an unhelpful
Oct 21 09:43:39 mx.example.com opendmarc[7977]: 4CGbb3aX1Pz2N:
intuit.com fail
I'm trying to use XCLIENT to replicate the issue so I can test, rinse & repeat.
Trying 1st from @gmail.com (or any domain i've tried _other_ than 'intuit.com')
using data pulled from postfix logs for a SUCCESSFUL [email protected] delivery,
@ an opened 'openssl s_client' session to my postfix external IP, injecting
XCLIENT NAME=mail-vs1-f46.google.com ADDR=209.85.217.46 PORT=40169
PROTO=ESMTP HELO=mail-vs1-f46.google.com DESTADDR=203.0.113.1 DESTPORT=25
MAIL FROM:<[email protected]>
RCPT TO:<[email protected]>
DATA
test message
(CR/LF)
.
(CR/LF)
mail passes all filters, and is delivered cleanly.
I'm able to repeat the success for any/all of the non-intuit.com senders I try.
Switching to the data pulled from postfix logs for a FAILED [email protected]
delivery,
again @ an opened 'openssl s_client' session to my postfix external IP,
injecting
XCLIENT NAME=55.57.138.139.in-addr.arpa.iphmx.com ADDR=139.138.57.55
PORT=62440 PROTO=ESMTP HELO=esa3.hc3812-35.iphmx.com DESTADDR=203.0.113.1
DESTPORT=25
MAIL FROM:<[email protected]>
RCPT TO:<[email protected]>
DATA
test message
(CR/LF)
.
(CR/LF)
fails in the session with
550 5.7.1 rejected by DMARC policy for intuit.com
and is not delivered.
Before I take this up as an opendmarc question (my config &/or bug), & do more
thorough digging re: intuit's published records,
(1) Is there anything obviously wrong/missing in that^ XCLIENT usage generally,
or in the specific intuit.com case above, that would suggest a cause for the
dmarc/milter FAIL, that 1st needs fixing?
I _suspect_ not, given the success with all _other_ domains ...
