Kris Deugau <kdeu...@vianet.ca> wrote: >jeffrey j donovan wrote: >> Greetings, >> >> Can someone explain this error to me, I have never seen this one >before. I tested my spf records and they seem fine. >> >>>> <someu...@ncem-pa.org>: host mail.ncem-pa.org[204.186.202.37] said: >554 >>>> 5.7.1 <someu...@ncem-pa.org>: Recipient address rejected: Failed >SPF >>>> check; beth.k12.pa.us, Redundant applicable 'v=spf1' sender >policies found >>>> (in reply to RCPT TO command) >>>> Reporting-MTA: dns; smtp5.beth.k12.pa.us >> >> in this , it looks like the user recipient address is incorrect or >something along those lines. >> I do have two spf records, one for my relays and one for google. > >I'm not completely clear on what you mean by "one for my relays and one >for google", but you have two SPF records published publicly. Don't Do >That. (I don't think it's strictly a violation of the spec, but >clearly >the recipient is being picky.)
It is an error. The recipient is choosing to reject based on an error condition that is specified in RFC 4408 (and still in the not quite released 4408bis). Scott K
