Wietse Venema put forth on 3/12/2011 9:00 AM:

> With Postfix, ALL SMTP DESTINATIONS are subject to MX lookup unless

Thank you for clarifying this Wietse.  I don't recall seeing this
explicitly stated in postconf 5, but I do recall seeing "use [] to
disable MX lookups" in the text of many parameters.  Since I rarely use
these parameters, I guess I simply never made the proper inference that
MX lookups are always performed by default.

> the destination is inside []. It would be a major WTF to break that
> rule for relayhost.

After your explanation I now understand the reason why disabling it with
[] is the responsibility of the admin--interface consistency.  However,
that was not the focus of my question, although my second attempt at
asking it was unfortunately worded in a way that led you to believe so.

The focus of my question was simply why/if doing MX lookups is ever
useful or necessary when one is sending all mail through a relayhost.
I'm unable to think of a scenario where it would be needed.  If there is
such a scenario I'd simply like to learn what it is.  This is why I
asked my original question, to fill in my knowledge gap here.

I've never claimed to be a Postfix or SMTP expert.  I have some
knowledge and I share it with others when I believe it may be helpful.
When I lack knowledge, I ask questions.  Please don't get frustrated
with me when I ask things that you feel I should already know.  If I
already knew them I wouldn't ask.

Note that I correctly answered the question of this thread.  Frank
implemented my suggestion and is pleased as punch with the results.  It
was the follow up suggestion from Andreas of using [] that brought us to
the current discussion, prompting my MX lookup question WRT relayhost.

-- 
Stan

Reply via email to