On 10/24/2010 8:13 PM, [email protected] wrote:
I have a mail user with obviously a mixed up MUA setup (Thunderbird). This
mail user cannot send out Email to any Email address belonging to foreign
mail servers. He only succeeds to send Email to users on the same mailserver
(mine).

The principal problem (wrong MUA settings) is clear but I just would like to
fully understand the related postfix logline 100% right (to be able to give
more DETAILED advice to this MUA user.

My Email user is [email protected] (my mailservers)
He wants to send an Email to [email protected] (foreign mail server)

Here's the logline in question:

Oct 24 22:38:36 mail postfix/smtpd[91510]: NOQUEUE: reject: RCPT from
ANice-123-1-16-136.w82-144.abo.wanadoo.fr[123.123.123.123]: 554 5.7.1
<[email protected]>: Relay access denied;
from=<[email protected]>  to=<[email protected]>  proto=ESMTP
helo=<[192.168.0.4]>

So three times an Email address is mentioned in this logline. The meaning of
the second occuremce ("... from=<[email protected]>  ...") and third
occurence (".... to=<[email protected]>  ...")is clear. I just don't
get the exact meaning of the first occurence of an Email address.

Now the actual question:

Does the FIRST occurence of an Email address ( "... 554 5.7.1
<[email protected]>: Relay access denied ...") mean, that my client
tried to smtp auth himself as mailbox user [email protected] ?

Does this then mean that wrongfully this MUA setup has [email protected] in
the mail accounts configuration instead of [email protected] ?

The log line tells you nothing about AUTH, other than implying that the client didn't. A breakdown of the log entry:

> Oct 24 22:38:36 mail postfix/smtpd[91510]: NOQUEUE:

NOQUEUE: there was no queue file created.

> reject: RCPT

Request was rejected during the RCPT stage of the SMTP conversation.

> from
> ANice-123-1-16-136.w82-144.abo.wanadoo.fr[123.123.123.123]:

The remote client's verified hostname and IP.

> 554 5.7.1
> <[email protected]>: Relay access denied;

This is the response postfix sent to the remote client. The SMTP response is 554 (a permanent error) with an extended code of 5.7.1, and a text description of what was rejected (the recipient address) and why (relay access denied).


> from=<[email protected]> to=<[email protected]> proto=ESMTP
> helo=<[192.168.0.4]>

Postfix records the sender, recipient, protocol, and the HELO hostname log analysis.


For SASL errors, look for log entries with the client IP and "authentication failed", and logging provided by your SASL subsystem (cyrus or dovecot).


  -- Noel Jones





In this case, I had an approval on the wromg MUA setup. My postfix
configuration does exactly what it has to do: reject foreign users to avoid
being an open relay.

Many thanks in advance !

Tom

Reply via email to