On Fri, 19 Apr 2024 16:14:27 GMT, Andy Goryachev <ango...@openjdk.org> wrote:
>> So, none of them can be reproduced on windows, only on mac.
>>
>> The #2 can be reproduced in the version before PR and after PR.
>>
>> The #3 is reproducible only with PR changes and in my opinion an other bug
>> in JavaFX, which is made to appear by this PR.
>>
>> It can be quick-fixed by adding a ``Platform.runLater(..)`` into
>> WINDO_HIDDEN event handler:
>>
>> popup.addEventHandler(WindowEvent.WINDOW_HIDDEN, e -> {
>> // Quick-fix for MacOs:
>> // If an item is selected in the overflow list and we select
>> an item from the visible list,
>> // selection in the overflow list remains on opening the
>> overflow list for the first time but overflow icon becomes grey.
>> // If we open overflow list again, selection will get
>> removed.
>> Platform.runLater(() -> {
>> // Put the overflowed items back to the list,
>> // otherwise subsequent prefWidth(..)/prefHeight(..) may
>> return wrong values.
>> overflowItems.clear();
>> for (Node item : getSkinnable().getItems()) {
>> if (!box.getChildren().contains(item)) {
>> overflowItems.add(item);
>> }
>> }
>> });
>> });
>>
>>
>> What is your suggestion? Should it be **quick**-fixed in this PR or should a
>> new issue be created for it?
>
>> Should it be **quick**-fixed in this PR
>
> I would rather not.
>
> We *could* create a ticket named "improve focus handling in ToolBar" but then
> again, since no functionality is disabled, it will be a P5 (very low
> priority).
What @andy-goryachev-oracle mentioned above seems ok to me. If focus indicator
function is not broken, we can go ahead with this PR and create separate ticket
to fix other issues.
-------------
PR Comment: https://git.openjdk.org/jfx/pull/1434#issuecomment-2067559676
