Thanks for your answer and, the detailed explanations.

> The core dumps in question here are for when the OS panics.  Core dumps
> can be used by developers to look at what went wrong, but in order to do
> so, you may need everything that was in RAM at the time of the panic.

That answered my question fully, thanks.

> So...the kernel can dump to swap (whatever was in swap wasn't in RAM,
> thus wasn't part of what caused the panic).  On next boot, savecore will
> find the dump in swap, and save it to /var.
>
> So that means swap has to be at least the size of RAM and you have to
> have AT LEAST that much space FREE on your /var partition.  Your 256G
> SSD just got ~70G smaller.  Ouch.

Yes, that I understood.

> ... or ...
>
> you can look at the big picture and realize...
> 1) you probably aren't a developer.
> 2) you probably haven't seen a core dump.

Yep, true.

> 3) you probably wouldn't know what to do with the core dump.

Me not (who knows what comes in the future) but, a developer.

> 4) if you got a core dump and wanted to send it to a developer, a 32G
> core dump would probably create a lot of problems for everyone.

Yes, from the view of a user (I have no problems to admit, that I don't
know things), I don't expected, that a core dump really could have 32 GB
of size. As you say before - Ouch.

> 5) that's a freaking big chunk of your SSD devoted to stuff you are
> unlikely to ever do anything with!

Yep, I will delete swap and use it for other things.

> and thus, I'll suggest you just don't worry about it.  IF you manage to
> find a way to panic your machine, drop the memory waaaay down to 2G or
> so, reproduce it and worry about a 2G core dump.

Not possible, there are 4 x 8 GB in it. Where we are again at the size
problem from before.

> And -- even if you do have a system panic, very often developers can
> make sense out of what went wrong from the output of the debugger's
> trace and ps commands, rather than having to dig through an entire core
> dump.  This is always what they ask for FIRST.

Ok, I use OpenBSD only for some weeks / months more or less often. I got
back my ThinkPad from repair and took now more time to read things and
play around ... it is like a puzzle where you come across this kind of
questions.

Reply via email to