On 18/12/12 10:28, Jean-Marc Lasgouttes wrote:
> Le 18/12/12 10:14, Rainer M Krug a écrit :
>>> Sounds like a great idea. One question: would having an external but 
>>> faithful XML Lyx file 
>>> allow XLS-translations to XML-based word-processing formats? That would 
>>> solve once and for
>>> all (hopefully) the problem of the Lyx-->Word conversion that still plagues 
>>> those of us
>>> working in the Humanities (At least, it still affects me).
>> 
>> Not only Humanities - I am working in the field of Ecology, and nearly all 
>> co-authors use MS
>> Word, and most Journals hide their option of submitting LaTeX somewhere. So 
>> this would be
>> brilliant.
> 
> Don't be lured by the fact that XML presents itself as the solution to all 
> problems. I do not
> see how you could collaborate with co-authors using word, unless your 
> document is horribly
> simple.

Obviously not lossless or that straight forward - but I guess much easier then 
it is now. (even
Libre Office an Word do not play that nicely together - even if I use only 
docx, I get formating
issues when I get the file back. But these are things I can handle.

And actually, most documents are horribly simple, and how it looks in word is 
irrelevant (no
painting of formats necessary), as long as the *structure* is kept. Even images 
/ tables could be
skipped in word, as long as a placeholder is put there (or an image).

Cheers,

Rainer

> 
> Today, although LyX format has been designed to follow LaTeX concepts, 
> exchanging documents
> with latex users is not that simple. IMO sharing with word is not really 
> going to work.
> 
> What could maybe be possible is to export to word and from there repair the 
> file (or import
> and repair by hand).
> 
> JMarc
> 

Reply via email to