-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1

On 03/15/2015 07:26 PM, David A Case wrote:
> On Sat, Mar 14, 2015, Robert Susmilch wrote:
>> 
>> I have Googled a way to refer to numbered equations in text, such
>> as "See equation (3)" in Lyx but everything I read, whether from
>> other users or wikis, suggests labeling the already numbered
>> equations and then using the label to cross reference.
>> 
>> This seems absurd ....
> 
> This has been discussed before on this list.  The requirement to
> have a label makes good sense: how do you propose to refer to an
> equation that does not have a label?  Remember that its number will
> change as equations are added or removed, whereas the label will
> not change.
> 
> It seems like you may wish to have a cross reference that says the 
> following: "refer to the *current* equation (3), and update the
> number in the cross reference if the corresponding equation number
> changes."  This might be implemented by having LyX create a unique
> but hidden label for every numbered equation, and providing some
> sort of user interface to refer to it.
> 
> For good reasons or bad, this is not the way LyX and latex work.
> Note that numbered equations are no different in this respect than
> are numbered sections, etc.
> 
> ....dave case
> 
Dear Dave,

Yes I see this now about sections, I think that might be an oversight
IMHO.

I have been very busy with work, a two year old, and getting both
myself and wife back to college after 10 and 15 years away from school
respectively to write back to everyone.
- -- 
Respectfully,

Robert Susmilch
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v2
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=Dxu4
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----

Reply via email to