Diego Queiroz wrote:
> About the problem Jürgen Spitzmüller is complaining, I really don't see the
> problem. The spellchecker usually holds all nouns (proper or not) that are
> common in a language.

I'm not complaining. I was opposing to the idea to let LyX pass upcased letter 
downcased to the speller in order to make them recognized as "correct" (this 
is at least how I understood the proposal).

> Guillaume is a common name in France, but it is not in Brazil, for
> example. So it is natural if a portuguese spellchecker mark this name as
> wrong. Acronyms and some company names are naturally always marked as
> wrong, specially because they need to be double checked. If that word is
> important, you must include it on your personal dictionary. Even the MS
> Word
> spellchecker (that is currently the most mature spellchecker IMO), you
> experience very same behavior (actually, it ignore capitalized words by
> default, but this can be changed).
> 
> Therefore, I am against the idea of "if a word begins with an uppercase
> letter, treat it as correct". This is wrong, 

Exactly my words. You must have misread my elaborations completely.

> and I'm almost sure this is
> not desired in any language.

Well, in English, there is Title Casing in some contexts.

Jürgen

Reply via email to