I find it strange that "--Separator--" appears inside the environment
pulldown.  Instead, I think of it as a character similar to a line
break.  I would expect to see it under Insert-Formatting-'Environment
Break'.

Abdel> Yep, and this idea is not new. We discussed the possibility to use a
Abdel> double-enter with JMarc a while ago for breaking itemize or
list environments.

I searched, but couldn't find this specific discussion.  What was the
conclusion?

Ben>> I don't know what boxes are,
Günter> With "boxes" I mean the LyX insets like they are used for minipages,
Günter> comments, notes, etc. They are an established tool for "container" or
Günter> "separable" environments that ususally contain several paragraphs but
Günter> should stay separate.

Thanks for the explanation Günter, but I'm still confused.  Do you
mean Boxes=Insets?  Is it similar to the "Increase depth"
functionality (the right/left arrows in the "Extra" toolbar)?  Since
most normal environments don't appear in a box, I think it would be
strange to box environments like Theorem/Proof.

Günter> Insets are a clearly visible and established metaphor. They are
Günter> especially useful for environments that usually include paragraphs
Günter> of different type/style as you get the nesting for free.

I think I'd understand better with some examples.  I was thinking of
slides, but the nesting of slides makes no sense to me.

Günter> The new feature would be helpful for the power user, but hidden to the
Günter> uninitiated.

I disagree.  I've been using LyX for almost ten years, and somehow I
never discovered the "--Separator--" environment.  (Previously, my
workaround was to increase the environment depth.)  However, I
definitely would have discovered if double-enter made a separate
environment.

-Ben

Reply via email to