Unfortunately, I discovered that the change from auto to vfat was not the 
solution to the problem. I don't like **magic** or things that seem to happen 
for no reason. There's always a reason - we just have to find it.

After my previous message (about an hour ago), I decided to play with the 
device again before returning it to my friend tomorrow. I was again not able 
to save data. In fact, the situation was even worse. I could no longer even 
mount the device. I checked fstab and found that the /dev/sda1 entry was 
gone. I can only guess that kudzu periodically checks and updates fstab 
(maybe a cron job - I didn't check).

I added the /dev/sda1 entry manually and was able to mount and read data but 
again couldn't save data (using auto or vfat).

I then went to the **extreme** of re-booting and spoiling my uptime ;-) a few 
times with and without the device in the USB plug. What I discovered is that 
the device seems to work as expected **out-of-the-box** the first time only, 
regardless of whether I boot with the device in the plug or plug it in after 
booting. What I mean is that without changing from auto to vfat, I can read 
and write on the device.

But if I umount, remove the device from the plug and them plug it in and try 
again, I can no longer save data.

BTW - I have no idea why the change from auto to vfat worked yesterday. I 
didn't boot and it obviously wasn't the first time I'd plugged in the device, 
since as you all know, I'd been trying several suggestions that didn't work 
before making the auto to vfat change :-(


-- 
Shlomo Solomon
http://come.to/shlomo.solomon
Sent by KMail (KDE 3.1) on LINUX Mandrake 9.1



=================================================================
To unsubscribe, send mail to [EMAIL PROTECTED] with
the word "unsubscribe" in the message body, e.g., run the command
echo unsubscribe | mail [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Reply via email to