Hi, sorry for the delay - i was busy making new flags for Lily.
2011/1/24 Phil Holmes <m...@philholmes.net> > > ----- Original Message ----- From: "Jan Warchoł" > <lemniskata.bernoulli...@gmail.com> > >> I don't agree. *Theoretically* accidental is not needed, but if it >> would be omitted, how can you tell the difference between aes~ | aes >> and aes( | a) ? >> In my opinion accidental here is necessary (surely it may be >> parenthesized). If it's necessary, it should be printed automatically >> in my opinion. > >> cheers, >> Janek > > If you use > > #(set-accidental-style 'modern-cautionary) > then you get the parenthesised accidental automatically, as requested. Indeed, thanks for the remainder. However, in my opinion it is necessary to *change* the 'default', 'voice' and 'forget' accidental styles, because their current behaviour result in wrongly typeset music. If the last note in the following example doesn't get a natural, it's *impossible* to tell that it's not another ces: ces'1~ | ces' ces'1( | c') It may be argued that the slur looks different than the tie, but it's not enough. I'm sure that engraving books will agree with me - may someone check this? cheers, Janek PS By the way, i think that modern-cautionary accidental style prints a cautionary accidental there not because of a potential confusion with a tie, but simply because it prints remainder accidentals in the following measure. _______________________________________________ lilypond-user mailing list lilypond-user@gnu.org http://lists.gnu.org/mailman/listinfo/lilypond-user
