Hello Hilton, Am Thu, Jul 03, 2025 at 11:57:39PM +0800 schrieb Hilton Chain: > - Require all changes to be submitted first. This is actually enforcing the > commit policy[2].
indeed I followed the policy after it came out, but we have been having problems with the tooling: QA was never able to keep up with the volume of submissions. So in practice, each time it amounted to doing some additional work for submitting the commit, then waiting for a week and committing the same changes and doing some additional work for closing the issue. So I gave up after a while and committed directly as before. This was helped by the addition of guix build -P 1 package-name that we can run locally. But I agree that it would be preferable to run all changes as PRs through QA. As for the distinction between team members and committers you ask about in your follow-up, I see a greater responsibility with committers, who sign the commits. I make sure to go through every commit I push. And they also have the responsibility (and ability) to react quickly of their commit poses problems, and at the least revert it if necessary. Andreas
