On 10/10/2015 03:54 PM, Manuel Rüger wrote: > > Dear Julian, > > avoiding this mailing list for further reviews is great news. > Still, I'd like to opt-out from receiving any mails arising from project > "Reviewers". > If there are QA-related issues with packages, I maintain, please file a > bug on bugs.gentoo.org. >
That's a great start for us, having developers announce publicly that they will ignore our project or require us to create bugs for every missing "|| die" in an ebuild. Not everything belongs on bugzilla. If there are common mistakes (e.g. missing SLOT :0 on openssl, libpng, jpeg and whatnot), we might still post them here, so that people are made aware of that. And that also has happened recently (I'd say not even half of the ebuilds I was looking at during my libressl work had a correct openssl depstring). Knowing that you will ignore all those mails is very motivating. I'll leave it to your own consideration whether that is in accordance with our CoC/social contract. But ignoring each other is already very common in gentoo and accepted practice, so what can I say. Nevertheless, we'll try to continue, reduce public noise and keep the reviews useful.
