I think these lines for "The Apache License 2.0" for the non-ASF are misleading (everything else is also Apache License) and is not required by the Apache license.
> The Apache License 2.0 > ----------------------------------------------------------------------- > This product includes Bootstrap Datepicker > (http://www.eyecon.ro/bootstrap-datepicker - Apache License - 2.0), Copyright > 2012 Stefan Petre. > This product includes bootstrap-transition.js v2.3.2 > (http://twbs.github.com/bootstrap/javascript.html#transitions - Apache > License - 2.0), Copyright 2013 Twitter, Inc. > This product includes Select2 3.4.3 (http://ivaynberg.github.io/select2/ - > Apache License - 2.0), Copyright 2012 Igor Vaynberg. > This product includes bootstrap-notify v1.0 > (http://goodybag.github.io/bootstrap-notify/ - Apache License - 2.0), > Copyright 2012 Goodybag, Inc. > This product includes Open Sans font (http://www.opensans.com/ - Apache > License - 2.0), © 2016 OpenSans.com > This product includes Jisql (https://bitbucket.org/stdunbar/jisql - Apache > License - 2.0), © 2004-2011 Scott Dunbar > This product includes PasswordComparisonAuthenticator.java in Spring Security > (https://github.com/spring-projects/spring-security - Apache License - 2.0), > Copyright 2004, 2005, 2006 Acegi Technology Pty Limited If the files already have (c) statements then those should be retained (e.g. as you've done for bootstrap-datepicker.js) , and if they already have a NOTICE than that content should be propagated (if applicable to your selected files). If you do that, then you should be in compliance with the Apache License. If the upstream has no (c) in file headers and no NOTICE of it's own, then I must admit it's unclear what to do; I would be brave and add their copyright to their files (as their copyright is kept even if not stated; unless published in the US before 1989) - but this can be tricky if the author's identity is unknown: "(c) github user penrose1337" :) (For the fonts binaries I think you can add a README.txt to the folder https://github.com/apache/incubator-ranger/tree/master/security-admin/src/main/webapp/fonts/fontopensans) On 20 June 2016 at 20:07, Velmurugan Periasamy <v...@apache.org> wrote: > Hi Justin: > > I would like to get your feedback on updated LICENSE.txt for Ranger. > https://github.com/apache/incubator-ranger/blob/master/LICENSE.txt > > Please see below answers to your questions. Ranger dev community is getting > prepared for the next major release, so getting your feedback and approval on > license would be critical. Thanks for your help. > > << > Minor issues: > LICENSE is missing MIT licensed Search Icon CSS copyright Nicolas Gallagher > bundled in (1) > Added PURE CSS GUI ICONS to LICENSE.txt > Is the copyright on this files correct? (2)(3) if so what projects did they > come from? (may effect content of NOTICE file) > (2) -> Added Jisql license. > (3) -> This file comes with Spring Security. Added that to LICENSE.txt > LICENSE is missing MIT licensed es5-shim copyright Kristopher Michael Kowal > bundled in (4) > Added to LICENSE.txt > LICENSE is missing SIL licensed FontAwesome (9) > Added to LICENSE.txt > LICENSE is missing reset.css. (7) Note this version bundled may not be public > domain unlike this one (8) so you may need to sort that out. > Added a note in LICENSE.txt > LICENSE is missing MIT licensed sizzle.js bundled in several files (10) > Added to LICENSE.txt > LICENSE is missing MIT license javascript diff engine in (11) > File was not used, removed the file. > I think handle bars require plugin is not WTFPL but MIT or BSD? (12) May > require further investigation. > Added a note in LICENSE.txt > LICENSE is missing public domain json2.js (13) > Added to LICENSE.txt > LICENSE is missing BSD licensed easing equations from Robert Penner (15) in > this file (14) > Added a note in LICENSE.txt > This is a more serious concern (and has been asked before): > How is this file licensed? (5) or this one? (6) > These files are not used, removed the files. > 1. > ./apache-ranger-incubating-0.5.3/security-admin/src/main/webapp/libs/bower/backgrid-filter/css/backgrid-filter.css > 2. > ./apache-ranger-incubating-0.5.3/jisql/src/main/java/org/apache/util/sql/Jisql.java > 3. > ./apache-ranger-incubating-0.5.3/security-admin/src/test/java/org/apache/ranger/service/PasswordComparisonAuthenticator.java > 4. > ./apache-ranger-incubating-0.5.3/security-admin/src/main/webapp/libs/other/backgrid/backgrid.js > 5. > ./apache-ranger-incubating-0.5.3/security-admin/src/main/webapp/libs/bower/globalize/generator/HijriCalendar.js > 6. > ./apache-ranger-incubating-0.5.3/security-admin/src/main/webapp/libs/bower/globalize/generator/UmAlQuraCalendar.js > 7. > ./apache-ranger-incubating-0.5.3/security-admin/src/main/webapp/libs/other/visualsearch/css/reset.css > 8. http://meyerweb.com/eric/tools/css/reset/reset.css > 9. > apache-ranger-incubating-0.5.3/security-admin/src/main/webapp/fonts/fontawesome/FontAwesome.otf > 10. ./security-admin/src/main/webapp/libs/bower/jquery/js/jquery.js > 11. ./security-admin/src/main/webapp/libs/bower/globalize/test/qunit/qunit.js > 12. > /security-admin/src/main/webapp/libs/bower/require-handlebars-plugin/js/hbs.js > 13. > ./security-admin/src/main/webapp/libs/bower/require-handlebars-plugin/js/json2.js > 14. > ./security-admin/src/main/webapp/libs/other/jquery-ui/js/jquery-ui-1.10.3.custom.js > 15 http://robertpenner.com/easing/ >>> > > Thank you, > Vel > > On May 20, 2016, at 11:25 AM, Velmurugan Periasamy <v...@apache.org> wrote: > >> Thank you so much Justin. I’ll do the below. >> >> 1] Initiate another RC for 0.5.3. >> 2] Track these issues in https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/RANGER-964 >> and target to address in 0.6.0 >> >> Regarding your question on [5] and [6] below, I believe these files are >> covered under jquery globalize license. I will double check and resolve it >> as needed in next release. >> >>> This is a more serious concern (and has been asked before): >>> - How is this file licensed? [5] or this one? [6] >> >> >> Thank you for your help, >> Vel >> >> On May 19, 2016, at 8:11 PM, Justin Mclean <jus...@classsoftware.com> wrote: >> >>> Hi, >>> >>> Still needs some work IMO but if a JIRA was raised to fix these issues in a >>> later release I’d vote +1 on a new RC without these fixes. Just as long as >>> it’s all sorted before graduation. >>> >>> Minor issues: >>> - LICENSE is missing MIT licensed Search Icon CSS copyright Nicolas >>> Gallagher bundled in [1] >>> - Is the copyright on this files correct? [2][3] if so what projects did >>> they come from? (may effect content of NOTICE file) >>> - LICENSE is missing MIT licensed es5-shim copyright Kristopher Michael >>> Kowal bundled in [4] >>> - LICENSE is missing SIL licensed FontAwesome [9] >>> - LICENSE is missing reset.css. [7] Note this version bundled may not be >>> public domain unlike this one [8] so you may need to sort that out. >>> - LICENSE is missing MIT licensed sizzle.js bundled in several files [10] >>> - LICENSE is missing MIT license javascript diff engine in [11] >>> - I think handle bars require plugin is not WTFPL but MIT or BSD? [12] May >>> require further investigation. >>> - LICENSE is missing public domain json2.js [13] >>> - LICENSE is missing BSD licensed easing equations from Robert Penner [15] >>> in this file [14] >>> >>> This is a more serious concern (and has been asked before): >>> - How is this file licensed? [5] or this one? [6] >>> >>> As there this is very complex there may of been a couple of things I missed. >>> >>> Thanks, >>> Justin >>> >>> 1. >>> ./apache-ranger-incubating-0.5.3/security-admin/src/main/webapp/libs/bower/backgrid-filter/css/backgrid-filter.css >>> 2. >>> ./apache-ranger-incubating-0.5.3/jisql/src/main/java/org/apache/util/sql/Jisql.java >>> 3. >>> ./apache-ranger-incubating-0.5.3/security-admin/src/test/java/org/apache/ranger/service/PasswordComparisonAuthenticator.java >>> 4. >>> ./apache-ranger-incubating-0.5.3/security-admin/src/main/webapp/libs/other/backgrid/backgrid.js >>> 5. >>> ./apache-ranger-incubating-0.5.3/security-admin/src/main/webapp/libs/bower/globalize/generator/HijriCalendar.js >>> 6. >>> ./apache-ranger-incubating-0.5.3/security-admin/src/main/webapp/libs/bower/globalize/generator/UmAlQuraCalendar.js >>> 7. >>> ./apache-ranger-incubating-0.5.3/security-admin/src/main/webapp/libs/other/visualsearch/css/reset.css >>> 8. http://meyerweb.com/eric/tools/css/reset/reset.css >>> 9. >>> apache-ranger-incubating-0.5.3/security-admin/src/main/webapp/fonts/fontawesome/FontAwesome.otf >>> 10. ./security-admin/src/main/webapp/libs/bower/jquery/js/jquery.js >>> 11. >>> ./security-admin/src/main/webapp/libs/bower/globalize/test/qunit/qunit.js >>> 12. >>> /security-admin/src/main/webapp/libs/bower/require-handlebars-plugin/js/hbs.js >>> 13. >>> ./security-admin/src/main/webapp/libs/bower/require-handlebars-plugin/js/json2.js >>> 14. >>> ./security-admin/src/main/webapp/libs/other/jquery-ui/js/jquery-ui-1.10.3.custom.js >>> 15 http://robertpenner.com/easing/ >>> --------------------------------------------------------------------- >>> To unsubscribe, e-mail: general-unsubscr...@incubator.apache.org >>> For additional commands, e-mail: general-h...@incubator.apache.org >>> >> > -- Stian Soiland-Reyes Apache Taverna (incubating), Apache Commons http://orcid.org/0000-0001-9842-9718 --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: general-unsubscr...@incubator.apache.org For additional commands, e-mail: general-h...@incubator.apache.org
