On Wednesday 04 October 2006 02:46, Noel J. Bergman wrote: > And then we've got Roy's comment that the Incubator PMC > isn't equipped to make those decisions, so that leaves us with what?
This has been a long thread to go thru for someone absent for a while... It has been very interesting. I understand Noel's PoV and "it will work, because we want to", but personally I find a lot of Justin's arguments really "strong" and "right". If the Proposer controls the Proposal (and not stick it on a freely editable Wiki), then isn't it very straight forward? You feel excluded (I have); Convince the Proposor that you belong. You feel "piling on" is happening; Ask the Proposer to qualify the selection criteria, and have a dialog if you find it "inappropriate". I mean, who cares if "Company X" starts a podling in ASF Incubator with 400 employees getting commit access to that project? If we change the wording in Graduation Criteria to include "maximum 30% of committers from the same company", then that excessive initial PPMC on the Proposal quickly becomes a handicap. Cheers Niclas --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
