Speaking from experience, something will break. I've been there. There's a reason why Red Carpet includes system update channels for your distro in addition to the desktop channel and any products you purchased... it's because they're creating an update path which has potential to be (and therefor eventually is) incompatible with the path provided via Mandrake.
In a way this points to another weakness of RPM, which is the ability to specify dependencies with something like foobar version >= 2.0. foobar2-1 and foobar-2-0.1 will fail, even though they have the right code inside them. Get two different distributors of the same libraries going on the same system, and sooner or later you're going to break something. If you go with Red Carpet, trust Ximian to do everything for you and quit using urpmi/rpmdrake. If you want to stick with urpmi/rpmdrake, then wait for Mandrake to package the rpms or build Ximian applications from .tgz. On Wed, 2002-12-18 at 11:27, Stefano Pogliani wrote: > Ok, I understand your point and I sympathize. > > But, let's put my question in another form: which is the risk of > installing some of the GNOME packages that are said to be required by > the new Evolution 1.2 and which are not signed by Mandrake ? > > If I install "libgtkhtml20, 1.0.4-6.ximian.1" as proposed by the new > Evolution, where currently I have "1.0.4-4mdk", > what will it happen when Mandrake will publish a version "1.0.4-6mdk" > or, anyway, a new version ? > > /stefano > > Jack Coates wrote: > > >On Wed, 2002-12-18 at 10:45, Robert Goshko wrote: > > > > > >>On Wed, 2002-12-18 at 09:09, Stefano Pogliani wrote: > >> > >> > >>>Rob, > >>> > >>> if you downloaded all the packages, then you manually did what Red > >>>Carpet did ! > >>>I mean, you installed some other packages that could, one day, conflict > >>>with the ones from Mandrake. > >>>Am I correct ? > >>> > >>> > >>Stefano, > >> > >>In theory, but from some of the postings I've seen on the Ximain User > >>mailing list, this seems to vary. I hear lots of people complaining > >>about how "Red Carpet did this and that to my system". > >> > >>I have never tried it so I cannot tell you first hand. I am always a > >>little "weary" of "just push the button and we will download what you > >>need and install it" software, call me old fashioned, but if the system > >>is going to get pooched, I would like to do it myself, at least I'll > >>know exactly what I did. > >> > >> > >> > > > >The thing about RPM auto-installers (urpmi too) is that they work fine > >when a distribution is fresh. The problems arise when you want to > >install new stuff on said distribution and have to update 7/10ths of the > >system to satisfy dependencies that may or may not actually exist in the > >world outside of the RPM database. > > > > > >------------------------------------------------------------------------ > > > >Want to buy your Pack or Services from MandrakeSoft? > >Go to http://www.mandrakestore.com > > > > -- Jack Coates Monkeynoodle: A Scientific Venture...
Want to buy your Pack or Services from MandrakeSoft? Go to http://www.mandrakestore.com
