> Paul Ebersman <mailto:list-dn...@dragon.net> > Sunday, November 02, 2014 7:55 AM > ... > So your grand scheme is decorum? > ... to limit who can get v6 PTRs and that will be > the new standard of whether or now you're tall enough to send email with > the big boys? yes. > How's that worked out so far in v4 in the last few years? thanks to steve's <http://www.enemieslist.com/> by which i "whiteout" the PTR's manufactured by last mile providers, and behave exactly as i would if these PTR's were not present -- it's working pretty well. seems like a lot of extra complexity though. > How about we admit that PTRs as a measure of trust and reputation is > broken to begin with and won't scale or magically work better for v6 > than v4? Let's come up with a better solution(s). i think we're on the same page, actually. where we're still far apart is in our understandings of how things work today, in other words, what status quo are we living with; and also, whether and in what direction we can change it.
-- Paul Vixie
_______________________________________________ DNSOP mailing list DNSOP@ietf.org https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/dnsop
