Read over the new DNSOP-titled version and have a couple of minor comments.
Section 3 - 1st paragraph: I am not a lawyer, but have had to deal with them on occasion. qname minimization may or may not reduce legal responsibilities. Just because you can't do something doesn't always absolve you from trying :) 4th paragraph: I'd suggest dropping the word "illegal" It's a loaded term and may not be true depending on the jurisdiction. last paragraph: Their is also a (small) performance hit for DANE aware applications where the owner name often has multiple labels. Might want to mention it as well. One way to reduce the time would be to not do minimization for certain qtypes (like TLSA, OPENPGPKEY, etc.). It doesn't gain much since the cache would have the authoritative server in it already, so it would reduce one query that would (possibly) hit an empty non-terminal per type. I guess this means I sign on as a reviewer, Scott =================================== Scott Rose NIST scott.r...@nist.gov +1 301-975-8439 Google Voice: +1 571-249-3671 http://www.dnsops.gov/ =================================== _______________________________________________ DNSOP mailing list DNSOP@ietf.org https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/dnsop
