Keith N. McKenna wrote:
Even though he is a PMC member his vote cannot be counted as binding as he did not build from source as is required by Apache Policy.
This is OK as long as the Apache Policy doesn't get in the way too much... I mean, I highly appreciate when people provide a list of what they did to justify their +1. But this shouldn't be used "against" them.
For example, our last blocker was only affecting binary builds for Mac and not even all Mac installations; but all of us agreed it was a blocker, even though it could have gone unnoticed if everybody just did the testing by Apache Policy.
So for sure we can keep the tally as it is, but I would tend to just count the +1s and -1s, and trust that a PMC member will cast a +1 only if he feels OK with it, rather than basing the tally on the descriptions. In the end, we really need +1s even from people who only test the binaries.
Regards, Andrea. --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: dev-unsubscr...@openoffice.apache.org For additional commands, e-mail: dev-h...@openoffice.apache.org
