I’m not really convinced we need attribution at all. The content is not being released as a component of anything.
Why can’t we have a general mention in NOTICE? If someone wants to put attribution in the source files, I have no problem with that. It does seem like a waste of effort though. On Jan 25, 2015, at 10:18 AM, Alex Harui <aha...@adobe.com> wrote: > > > On 1/25/15, 12:12 AM, "Harbs" <harbs.li...@gmail.com> wrote: > >> According to the link that Justin provided, there’s no need to add >> anything to the source file for public domain content. >> >> The only thing that should probably be done, is add something to the >> NOTICE that the tests contain public domain content. Nothing else needs >> to/should be done. > > I saw that, but would it be wrong to note it in the source? If we ever > release these files then yes, we need to mention it in NOTICE, but since > NOTICE must be tailored to package contents, I was thinking we’d leave it > out of NOTICE until we decide what goes in. Having some attribution in > the source might get it flagged by RAT so we catch it if we do include it > in a package. > > That said, I’m fine with just modifying NOTICE. > > -Alex > >> >> On Jan 25, 2015, at 10:10 AM, Alex Harui <aha...@adobe.com> wrote: >> >>> Thanks for the list. I haven’t looked to verify any of it. >>> >>> Let’s discuss the alice.xml file header. It still seems to me that >>> having >>> the Apache header is correct as the text was significantly modified to >>> have TextFlow markup in it. I think all that is missing is some comment >>> or text in there providing attribution. FWIW, my training from the Adobe >>> lawyers is that there may not be one correct answer when there is mixed >>> content. You just have to make sure everyone’s IP is correctly >>> accounted >>> for. >>> >>> Can you post what you think the header should be? And can you explain >>> why >>> it should be different than the way we handled the CC content in Tour De >>> Flex? Like this file: >>> >>> flex-utilities/TourDeFlex/TourDeFlex3/src/apache/ApacheFlex4_10_0.mxml >>> [1] >>> >>> >>> [1] >>> >>> https://fisheye6.atlassian.com/browse/flex-utilities/TourDeFlex/TourDeFle >>> x3 >>> /src/apache/ApacheFlex4_10_0.mxml?hb=true >>> [1] http://s.apache.org/48C (shortened) >>> >>> I’m out of time for tonight so I won’t see your reply until sometime >>> tomorrow for me. >>> >>> Thanks, >>> -Alex >>> >>> On 1/24/15, 10:51 PM, "Justin Mclean" <jus...@classsoftware.com> wrote: >>> >>>> Hi, >>>> >>>> OK I looked though the TLF code in version control and here's the list >>>> of >>>> what I found. >>>> >>>> I may of missed some things and this is not a complete list but I've >>>> run >>>> out of time. >>>> >>>> Jar in version control: >>>> ./ant/flexUnitTasks.jar >>>> >>>> Swcs in version control: >>>> ./libs/flexunit-cilistener.swc >>>> ./libs/flexunit-uilistener.swc >>>> ./libs/flexunit.swc >>>> >>>> Missing Apache headers: >>>> ./automation_core/src/UnitTest/ExtendedClasses/TestCaseBase.as >>>> ./automation_core/src/UnitTest/Fixtures/MeasureConstants.as >>>> ./automation_tests/src/UnitTest/Tests/SimpleTest.as >>>> ./sdk/samples/actionscript/FTE/build-asFTE.xml >>>> ./sdk/samples/actionscript/Pagination/build-Pagination.xml >>>> ./sdk/samples/actionscript/TextLayout/build-asTLF.xml >>>> ./sdk/samples/flex/build-flex.xml >>>> ./sdk/samples/flex/TextLayoutEditor/build-editor.xml >>>> ./sdk/samples/flex/textLayout_editBar/build-editBar.xml >>>> ./test/testSuites.xml >>>> ./test/testCases/AllEventTest.xml >>>> ./test/testCases/ContainerAttributeTests.xml >>>> ./test/testCases/ContainerTypeTests.xml >>>> ./test/testCases/EventOverrideTest.xml >>>> ./test/testCases/FactoryImportTests.xml >>>> ./test/testCases/FontEmbedTest.xml >>>> ./test/testCases/HorizontalScrollingTests.xml >>>> ./test/testCases/ImpliedParagraphTest.xml >>>> ./test/testCases/ImportTests.xml >>>> ./test/testCases/KeyboardGestureTest.xml >>>> ./test/testCases/LocaleTests.xml >>>> ./test/testCases/MXMLCompilationTest.xml >>>> ./test/testCases/MeasurementTest.xml >>>> ./test/testCases/OperationTest.xml >>>> ./test/testCases/ParagraphTest.xml >>>> ./test/testCases/SWFTest.xml >>>> ./test/testCases/ScrollToRangeTest.xml >>>> ./test/testCases/ScrollingTest.xml >>>> ./test/testCases/SelectionTest.xml >>>> ./test/testCases/StyleTests.xml >>>> ./test/testCases/TCYTests.xml >>>> ./test/testCases/TabTest.xml >>>> ./test/testCases/TextContainerManagerTest.xml >>>> ./test/testCases/TextFlowTextlineFactoryTest.xml >>>> ./test/testCases/TextLineFilterTest.xml >>>> ./test/testCases/UndoRedoTest.xml >>>> ./test/testCases/VerticalScrollingTests.xml >>>> ./test/testCases/WritingModeTests.xml >>>> ./test/testCases/sampleDataTests.xml >>>> ./test/testFiles/markup/plainText/asknot.txt >>>> ./test/testFiles/markup/tlf/AliceID.xml >>>> ./test/testFiles/markup/tlf/TextFrameTests.xml >>>> ./test/testFiles/markup/tlf/adornmentTest.xml >>>> ./test/testFiles/markup/tlf/backgroundColorTest.xml >>>> ./test/testFiles/markup/tlf/emptyElements.xml >>>> >>>> licence issues: >>>> ./sdk/samples/actionscript/Logo.jpg (Adobe registered logo) >>>> ./sdk/samples/flex/Logo.jpg (Adobe registered logo) >>>> ./test/testFiles/assets/ARIAL_FONT.swf (Font we don't have permission >>>> to use) >>>> ./test/testFiles/assets/FremontBridge.jpg (Photograph of unknown >>>> provenance) >>>> ./test/testFiles/assets/FremontBridge.swf (as above) >>>> ./test/testFiles/assets/carrot.png (Image of unknown provenance) >>>> ./test/testFiles/assets/gandhi.jpg (likely public domain image no >>>> attribution) >>>> ./test/testFiles/assets/gremlin.jpg (Photograph of unknown provenance) >>>> ./test/testFiles/assets/image1.jpg (as above) >>>> ./test/testFiles/assets/leaves.jpg (as above) >>>> ./test/testFiles/markup/plainText/asknot.txt (public domain no >>>> attribution) >>>> ./test/testFiles/markup/tlf/AliceID.xml (copyright expired/public >>>> domain, missing license no attribution) [1] >>>> ./test/testFiles/markup/tlf/HORLTRAUTO.xml (copyright expired/public >>>> domain, incorrectly apache licensed and no attribution) [2] >>>> ./test/testFiles/markup/tlf/HORLTRHARD.xml (copyright expired/public >>>> domain, incorrectly apache licensed and no attribution) [2] >>>> ./test/testFiles/markup/tlf/HORRTLAUTO.xml (copyright expired/public >>>> domain, incorrectly apache licensed and no attribution) [2] >>>> ./test/testFiles/markup/tlf/HORRTLHARD.xml (copyright expired/public >>>> domain, incorrectly apache licensed and no attribution) [2] >>>> ./test/testFiles/markup/tlf/HtmlTest.xml (copyright expired/public >>>> domain, incorrectly apache licensed and no attribution) [2] >>>> ./test/testFiles/markup/tlf/JapaneseSampleMac.xml (copyright Adobe, >>>> incorrectly apache licensed) [3] >>>> ./test/testFiles/markup/tlf/JapaneseSampleWin.xml l (copyright Adobe, >>>> incorrectly apache licensed) [3] >>>> ./test/testFiles/markup/tlf/ParaAlignLTR.xml (copyright expired/public >>>> domain, incorrectly apache licensed and no attribution) [2] >>>> ./test/testFiles/markup/tlf/ParaAlignRTL.xml (copyright expired/public >>>> domain, incorrectly apache licensed and no attribution) [2] >>>> ./test/testFiles/markup/tlf/ParaAlignVertical.xml (copyright >>>> expired/public domain, incorrectly apache licensed and no attribution) >>>> [2] >>>> ./test/testFiles/markup/tlf/RTLTabs.xml (copyright UN, incorrect apache >>>> licensed) [4] >>>> ./test/testFiles/markup/tlf/VA-Justify.xml (copyright expired/public >>>> domain, incorrectly apache licensed and no attribution) [2] >>>> ./test/testFiles/markup/tlf/VORLTRAUTO.xml (copyright expired/public >>>> domain, incorrectly apache licensed and no attribution) [2] >>>> ./test/testFiles/markup/tlf/VORLTRHARD.xml (copyright expired/public >>>> domain, incorrectly apache licensed and no attribution) [2] >>>> ./test/testFiles/markup/tlf/VORRTLAUTO.xml (copyright expired/public >>>> domain, incorrectly apache licensed and no attribution) [2] >>>> ./test/testFiles/markup/tlf/VORRTLHARD.xml (copyright expired/public >>>> domain, incorrectly apache licensed and no attribution) [2] >>>> ./test/testFiles/markup/tlf/VSAUTO.xml (copyright expired/public >>>> domain, incorrectly apache licensed and no attribution) [2] >>>> ./test/testFiles/markup/tlf/alice.xml (copyright expired/public >>>> domain, incorrectly apache licensed and no attribution) [1] >>>> ./test/testFiles/markup/tlf/aliceExcerpt.xml (copyright expired/public >>>> domain, incorrectly apache licensed and no attribution) [1] >>>> ./test/testFiles/markup/tlf/alice_with_links.xml (copyright >>>> expired/public domain, incorrectly apache licensed and no attribution) >>>> [1] >>>> ./test/testFiles/markup/tlf/asknot-discretionaryhyphens.xml (public >>>> domain, incorrectly apache licensed and no attribution) [5] >>>> ./test/testFiles/markup/tlf/asknot.xml /public domain, incorrectly >>>> apache licensed and no attribution) [5] >>>> ./test/testFiles/markup/tlf/asknot_discretionaryhyphens.xml (public >>>> domain, incorrectly apache licensed and no attribution) [5] >>>> ./test/testFiles/markup/tlf/barnsley.xml (copyright expired/public >>>> domain, incorrectly apache licensed and no attribution) [6] >>>> ./test/testFiles/markup/tlf/barnsley_linkified.xml (copyright >>>> expired/public domain, incorrectly apache licensed and no attribution) >>>> [6] >>>> ./test/testFiles/markup/tlf/ethanBrandHyphen.xml (copyright >>>> expired/public domain, incorrectly apache licensed and no attribution) >>>> [2] >>>> ./test/testFiles/markup/tlf/font-embedding.xml (copyright >>>> expired/public domain, incorrectly apache licensed and no attribution) >>>> [2] >>>> ./test/testFiles/markup/tlf/font_embedding.xml (copyright >>>> expired/public domain, incorrectly apache licensed and no attribution) >>>> [2] >>>> ./test/testFiles/markup/tlf/graphics_example.xml (text of unknown >>>> provenance) >>>> ./test/testFiles/markup/tlf/sampleArabic.xml (copyright UN, incorrect >>>> apache licensed) [4] >>>> ./test/testFiles/markup/tlf/severalPages.xml (copyright expired/public >>>> domain, incorrectly apache licensed and no attribution) [2] >>>> ./test/testFiles/markup/tlf/simple.xml (copyright expired/public >>>> domain, incorrectly apache licensed and no attribution) [2] >>>> ./test/testFiles/markup/tlf/simpleStyle.xml (copyright expired/public >>>> domain, incorrectly apache licensed and no attribution) [2] >>>> ./test/testFiles/markup/tlf/simple_colored.xml (copyright >>>> expired/public domain, incorrectly apache licensed and no attribution) >>>> [2] >>>> ./test/testFiles/markup/tlf/simple_with_links.xml (copyright >>>> expired/public domain, incorrectly apache licensed and no attribution) >>>> [2] >>>> ./test/testFiles/markup/tlf/tableExample.xml (Text from article on >>>> climate change in the New York Times?) >>>> ./test/testFiles/markup/tlf/tanach.xml (Text from Bible in Hebrew, may >>>> or may not be copyright or public domain. Given it's in electronic form >>>> there's a chance it may be this [7] which is public domain. Incorrectly >>>> apache licensed and no attribution) >>>> ./testApps/src/gandhi.mxml (content likely from wikipedia. Incorrectly >>>> apache licensed and no attribution) >>>> ./testApps/src/school.mxml (copyright UN, incorrect apache licensed) >>>> [4] >>>> ./testApps/src/schoolV.mxml (copyright UN, incorrect apache licensed) >>>> [4] >>>> >>>> There are likely to be further issues in: >>>> ./asTestApps/src (files names Alice) >>>> ./automation_tests/src/UnitTest/PerformanceTests (file names contain >>>> Alice) >>>> >>>> Thanks, >>>> Justin >>>> >>>> 1.http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alice%27s_Adventures_in_Wonderland >>>> 2. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ethan_Brand >>>> 3. http://www.adobe.com/type/browser/pdfs/OTGuideJ.pdf >>>> 4. http://www.un.org/ar/documents/udhr/ >>>> 5. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:JFK_inaugural_address.ogg >>>> 6. >>>> >>>> https://www.marxists.org/history/england/chartists/barnsley-manifesto.ht >>>> m >>>> 7 >>>> >>>> https://www.biblegateway.com/versions/The-Westminster-Leningrad-Codex-WL >>>> C/ >>>> 8 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mahatma_Gandhi >>>> >>>> >>> >> >
