On Sun, Feb 27, 2022 at 9:13 PM Jarek Potiuk <ja...@potiuk.com> wrote:
> > > > > > Do any of the mentioned alternatives fulfill those requirements? > > > > I think most - with very little investment on taking backup (same as we do > with ponymail today). > > Two examples: > > * http://apache-airflow.slack-archives.org/ Apache Airflow public slack. > searchable and owned by us: Developed by one of our PMC members in his free > time. Solves "public", "owned", "searchable". With little effort can be > made offline-usable (it's a simple web app that loads the backup of slack > messages), It even looks nice. The only thing it lacks currently is support > for thread display. > This is VERY nice! I'd really like to see some kind of a public searchability on all popular ASF slack channels. > * For Github discussion as I mentioned before it's just making sure you > subscribe to emails (same as current Ponymail backup). > > I think it's not a matter of "limitation" of certain media, bit more a > question of a little "investment" into some popular solutions to make them > fulfill the requirements we have and a way that INFRA provides instructions > and possible some little infrastructure and possibly "verification" for > those popular media used by different PMC. Same as currently providing > support for Ponymail (which is essentially a 3rd-party tool as well), > > It is more effort to support more solutions - yes, but INFRA can also tap > into support of the PMCs that want to use different tools to help with > making the effort to make it "blessed". > Yeah, I'm thinking that perhaps what is emerging from this thread is a requirement to have some tooling that would allow ANYTHING -> ASF ML flow (just for archive and searchabililty purposes). Or will this be too useless for more "real time" style communications? Thanks, Roman.
