On 22.02.25 09:25, Sébastien Noel wrote:
Control: tags -1 -moreinfo
Hi,
On 21/02/25 22:07, Phil Wyett wrote:Control: tags -1 +moreinfo [...]I used to find value in your reviews, but i'm doubtful with this one... The package pass all your tests but you conclude that it "is not yet ready". What is wrong with the package ?Is it a missing "yes" to your question "Will this package be imported into Salsa?" that triggers the "red flag" ?
I have the feeling that Phil runs some kind of automated test suites, but does not really have a technical closer look at the source package. E.g. the licenserecon checks if the license statements are consistent, but it does not check if the license of packages are DFSG conformal (maybe I'm missing something here). So his test suite is definitely a very good first step, but not sufficient to determine if a package can be pushed to the archive.
IMHO his test suite should be built into mentors, so every package, which is uploaded to mentors should be checked automatically. No, I don't volunteer to implement this.
H. -- Testmail
OpenPGP_signature.asc
Description: OpenPGP digital signature
