Marco,

On Tuesday, November 26, 2024 1:32:21 AM MST Marco M. F. De Santis wrote:
> > d/copyright      | licensecheck
> > 
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           aggiorna.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           api.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           base.js
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           clienti.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           costanti.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           costi.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           creaanno.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           crea_backup.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           creadb.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           crea_modelli.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           creaprezzi.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           crearegole.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           dati_relutenti.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           disponibilita.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           gestione_utenti.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           includes/costanti.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           includes/dati_form_prenotazione.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           includes/dati_lista_cassa.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           includes/dati_lista_clienti.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           includes/dati_lista_prenota.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           includes/files_sorgente.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           includes/foot.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           includes/funzioni_aggiorna.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           includes/funzioni_anno.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           includes/funzioni_appartamenti.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           includes/funzioni_backup.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           includes/funzioni_clienti.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           includes/funzioni_contratti.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           includes/funzioni_costi_agg.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           includes/funzioni_dati_relutenti.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           includes/funzioni_email.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           includes/funzioni_ins_prenota.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           includes/funzioni_log.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           includes/funzioni_menu.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           includes/funzioni_mod_contratti.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           includes/funzioni_mod_prenota.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           includes/funzioni_mysql_extra.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           includes/funzioni_mysqli_extra.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           includes/funzioni_mysqli.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           includes/funzioni_mysql.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           includes/funzioni.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           includes/
funzioni_postgresql_extra.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           includes/funzioni_postgresql.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           includes/funzioni_quadro_disp.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           includes/funzioni_relutenti.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           includes/funzioni_sqlite_extra.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           includes/funzioni_sqlite.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           includes/funzioni_tariffe.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           includes/funzioni_testo.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           includes/funzioni_web.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           includes/head.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+
> > includes/interconnect/aggiorna_ic_fork.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           includes/interconnect/aggiorna_ic.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           includes/liberasettimane.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           includes/sett_gio.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           includes/spezzaprenota.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           includes/templates/
aggiorna_modelli.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           includes/templates/cal/form.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           includes/templates/cal/functions.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           includes/templates/cal/name.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           includes/templates/cal/phrases.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           includes/templates/cal/template.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           includes/templates/cal/themes.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           includes/templates/cal/var.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           includes/templates/frasi_mod_disp.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+          
> > includes/templates/funzioni_mod_disp.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           includes/templates/
funzioni_modelli.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+
> > includes/templates/modello_disponibilita.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           includes/templates/rat/form.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           includes/templates/rat/functions.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           includes/templates/rat/name.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           includes/templates/rat/phrases.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           includes/templates/rat/template.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           includes/templates/rat/themes.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           includes/templates/rat/var.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           includes/templates/temi_mod_disp.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           includes/variabili_contratto.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           inizio.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           interconnessioni.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           inventario.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           messaggi.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           modifica_app.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           modifica_cliente.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           modifica_contratto.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           modifica_costi.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           modifica_ospiti.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           modifica_prenota.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           modifica_var_contr.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           mostra_sorgente.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           personalizza.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           prenota.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           privilegi_utenti.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           punto_vendita.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           storia_soldi.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           tabella2.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           tabella3.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           tabella.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           tab_tariffe.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           themes/blu/inc/functions.js
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           themes/blu/php/foot.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           themes/blu/php/head.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           themes/blu/php/menu.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           themes/blu/php/name.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           themes/blu/php/selectperiod.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           themes/col/inc/functions.js
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           themes/col/php/foot.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           themes/col/php/head.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           themes/col/php/menu.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           themes/col/php/name.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           themes/col/php/selectperiod.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           themes/sim/inc/functions.js
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           themes/sim/php/foot.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           themes/sim/php/head.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           themes/sim/php/menu.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           themes/sim/php/name.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           themes/sim/php/selectperiod.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           themes/snj/php/foot.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           themes/snj/php/head.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           themes/snj/php/menu.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           themes/snj/php/name.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           themes/snj/php/selectperiod.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           visualizza_contratto.php
> > AGPL-3           | AGPL-3+           visualizza_tabelle.php
> > 
> > Something to possibly look at for a future upload.
> 
> All files have for license version "either version 3 of the License, or
> any later version accepted by Marco Maria Francesco De Santis, which
> shall act as a proxy as defined in Section 14 of version 3 of the
> license", so not being "at your option any later version" I think it's
> better not to use AGPL-3+.

When I have encountered these situations, I give the license name in debian/
copyright a custom extension to easily indicate to users that it isn’t the 
standard license.  Something like AGPL-3~DeSantis, with a comment explaining 
how the license is different when it isn’t readily obvious.  You can see an 
example of this at:

https://salsa.debian.org/soren/feather-wallet/-/blob/main/debian/copyright?
ref_type=heads

(See the comments on the GPL-2-or-3-only and ISC-old licenses, the GPL-2-or-3-
only being the most similar to this case, where it isn’t strictly a GPL-2 and 
it isn’t strictly a GPL-2+.)

-- 
Soren Stoutner
so...@debian.org

Attachment: signature.asc
Description: This is a digitally signed message part.

Reply via email to