On Thu, 30 May 2024 16:16:59 GMT, Scott Gibbons <sgibb...@openjdk.org> wrote:
>> I agree with @eme64 to postpone the integration after JDK 23 is forked in >> one week. It is not about how you confident with code. It is size of code. I >> did only limited (tier1-4) testing in our infra which did not cover all our >> testing configuration. > > @vnkozlov OK. I'll defer to you all. I've contacted the author of the > fuzzer to see what I can do to set up a local instance. Would this be > sufficient to increase confidence for future submissions? We can run it > perpetually on fixes (provided I can set it up). Had I done that, we could > have had 6 months of fuzzing on top of our tests. Would that have alleviated > this concern? @asgibbons I generally just stop pushing ANY RFE's a week or two before the fork. Even if you did run the fuzzer with it - there are often last-minute changes. And your code here is rather large, so even if you are confident, there must be at least one bug hiding. Running the fuzzer is nice as pre-integration, but it mostly only catches things post-integration. ------------- PR Comment: https://git.openjdk.org/jdk/pull/16753#issuecomment-2140136262
