Hi Hideki,

thanks for your fine translation and all the information.
I will give some comments in between.

> The winning rate of this new version against previous version ("Saikyo 
> no Igo 2011") is 78%, stronger about 1 stone.

That sound impressive.
 
> "Crazy Stone" is a Go playing program, developed by a computer 
> scientist Rémi Coulom at Lille University in France.  A pioneer of 
> Monte-Carlo Go and one of the top-runners.

Just in these days I am finalizing a paper on "history of game tree
search". It starts with Zermelo (and his seminal paper in 1912).
Remi is mentioned in the paper too - for his first MCTS paper (published
in 2007) and for his Gold medal in the 2006 Olympiad.

> This product uses the newest version and, in addition, has "analysis 
> window" feature, which is very useful for anaylizing and research of  
> games.

We need it in Western version, too.

>    Restarting feature: When you have a doubt on a computer's move, you 
> can change the move and resume playing.

Very nice option. That makes it especially interesting for stronger players
for interactive analysis.

> - Perfect basic functinality.
>  Possbile settings are: Three boardsizes, 9, 13 and 19.  Handicap stones 
> from 0 to 9.  Komi from -7.5 to 7.5.

I would have prefered more flexible board sizes (ManyFaces allows all from
5x5 to 19x19; Leela allows all until 38x38(.
But more important would be to have more flexibility with komi and handicap
stones: ManyFaces allows any values from -99 to +999 for komi, and any 
number of handicap stones.
Extreme values are helpful when you want to play a game of "kill-all go":
One side gets many handicap stones. The other side is winner when she gets
one living group on the board.

*****************
One question to the Zen team:
Will there be (hopefully still in 2012) a commercial version for the western
people?

Thanks again for you detailled description and translation.
Ingo.
-- 
NEU: FreePhone 3-fach-Flat mit kostenlosem Smartphone!                          
        
Jetzt informieren: http://mobile.1und1.de/?ac=OM.PW.PW003K20328T7073a
_______________________________________________
Computer-go mailing list
[email protected]
http://dvandva.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/computer-go

Reply via email to