This is what you said Josh Fisher
>
> Scott Ruckh wrote:
>> I am running CentOS 4.5 x64 with self compiled kernel 2.6.13.4.  I have
>> installed the latest bacula 2.2.4 Director, Client, and Storage daemon
>> on
>> this server.
>>
>> Bacula run flawlessly most of the time.
>>
>> Unfortunately when I run VMWare Workstation and have a virtual machine
>> running, Bacula crashes the entire system.  I am running the latest
>> version of the 5.x series of VMWare.  I am also running fluxbox as my
>> Window Manager, although I don't think that has anything to do with the
>> problem.
>>
>> This problem has existed with all versions of Bacula starting with
>> 1.3.8.11 which is the first version I installed.
>>
>> My backups are to an external USB disk connected to the Host OS.
>>
>> The virtual machine is not configured with USB port because at one time
>> I
>> thought there might be contention between the Physical USB disk and the
>> USB port configured with the Virtual Machine.
>>
>> All virtual machines and host system work fine when bacula backups are
>> not
>> running.
>>
>> I have tested this with all sorts of guest Virtual Machines and the
>> results are the same; bacula will crash (completely unusable) the host
>> machine.  The only recovery method it to reboot the server.
>>
>
> All bacula daemons are running in user mode and only the FD is running
> as root. A hard lock like this means something is amiss at the kernel
> mode level. You could try backing up to a directory on SCSI/SATA/IDE
> disk as a test. If all works as expected when backing up to the non-USB
> drive, then maybe something is wrong in the way USB is being
> virtualized/configured.
>
>> Is anyone else successfully running a similar environment?  As bacula is
>> the only program that appears to cause the problem I am making an
>> assumption it is a problem with bacula.
>>
>> If anyone has this type of environment working successfully I would like
>> to hear about it.
>>

I had reported it was believed that not backing up the VMware disk files
of a live virtual machine solved the problem.  Unfortunately I was wrong
and the problem persists.

Now that more testing has been completed, I can officially say the problem
still exists.

I recompiled the kernel, upgraded VMWare Workstation (to version 6),
Upgraded VMWare Tools, and rebuilt all the VMWare modules using the same
gcc that the kernel was built with, but none of that helped.  I have the
exact same issue.

Unfortunately the problem is not always present as the backups do complete
some of time.  The only constant is that the hard crash only happens when
bacula is running.

Although the VM is not configured with a USB device there might possibly
be some contention with the physical USB drive I back up to and the VM
instance.  As the crash does not happen every time it is hard to determine
what exactly is going on.

As no other programs really access the USB device, and the crash only
happens when bacula is running, I am just guessing the problem might be
with that combination.

I know this is not really a priority on anyone's list, but I thought I
would keep everyone informed who might have been following this thread.

Thanks.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------
This SF.net email is sponsored by: Microsoft
Defy all challenges. Microsoft(R) Visual Studio 2005.
http://clk.atdmt.com/MRT/go/vse0120000070mrt/direct/01/
_______________________________________________
Bacula-users mailing list
Bacula-users@lists.sourceforge.net
https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/bacula-users

Reply via email to