I didnt read Gomz saying JTYJN superior than Dilse.. And I have read many times in the past Gomz saying Dil Se as one among the best.
--- In [email protected], V S Rawat <vsra...@...> wrote: > > On 8/18/2010 6:10 PM India Time, _Gomzyâ¢_ wrote: > > > well said aj. i find jtyjn a masterpiece. > > if jtyjn can be a masterpiece, then Dil Se was could not have been > composed by ARR, that must have been composed by God Himself. > > > sadly it wasnt well used or > > atleast not used properly. the songs needed a college story and not a > > post college story. > > Oh, Gomzy at conceptualization??? What a new beginning!!! eventually!!!! > > :-) :-) :-) :-) :-) :-) :-) :-) :-) > > Let me test him. > > Please give more examples what type of songs need a college story and > what kind of songs need post college story. > > Humse hai muqabla was a college story, but patti rap and urvashi were > college songs, ok, count premika ne pyar se also a college song, rest > all were post college songs? duniya dilwalo ki's only hello doctor was > college song, rest were post college songs. dil hi dil me's maria was > college song, rest were post college. Jeans' columbus was college, > rest were post college. > > RDB was a post college story, rather well past college, they were 5-6 > years or more past college. how come those college songs ru ba ru, > pathshala merged so well in a post-college story? > > -- > And then, those of us fans who were in college during 90s and liked > the college songs given by ARR at that time, now we are in 40s, > well-past college, how could we like RDB's college songs. > > -- > > What are the elements of a college song? talking about girls, love, > chhutti, books, masti, drinks, picnic, kiddish lyrics or bookish > ideology lyrics? > > -- > Hope Amit Chandran reads Gomzy's post and adds his views on the topic > as he is good at such conceptualizations. > > -- > rawat >
